Umm..didn''t they have insurance?
And 10mths after the ring was bought? Sorry, but I would want more info before siding with the consumer on this one - her attitude gave me a chuckle though
"It wasn''t as if I treated it roughly. I told them (the jewellers), ''Do these look like hands that do manual labour?''."
"In the Santis'' statement of claim lodged with the Federal Magistrates'' Court they value the diamond at $98,000 and a replacement setting at about $25,000."
Seems most have insurance on "inexpensive" $5K rings. . .If I were the judge, I''d toss that one right out of court.