Loose diamond quote - fair?

[The3rdMan]

I just got a quote for diamonds - are these fair? I tried to make the table easy to read - not sure how successful I was.


Shape Ct Color Clarity Measure. Depth Table Polish Symm. Fluor. Lab Pr/Ct Total Price
EUR 1.52 H VS2 7.14 - 7.37 x 4.64 65.00% 48% GD GD None EGLUS $7,375.00 $11,210.00
EUR 1.54 G VS1 7.10 - 7.37 x 4.50 62.20% 53% GD GD MedBlue EGL $10,266.00 $15,809.64
EUR 1.56 H VS2 7.20 - 7.49 x 4.61 64.00% 60% GDFR GD None EGLUS $7,375.00 $11,505.00
EUR 1.72 H VS2 7.66 - 7.79 x 4.54 58.80% 58% GD GD None EGLUS $7,876.00 $13,546.72
RD 1.42 Blue VS1 7.13 x 7.06 x 4.50 63.5% 60% EGL $2,780.00 $3,947.60

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Are the first 4 Old European cuts? You'd absolutely have to have pictures to select one of these. The last one is too deep and the table is too large (not to mention the color says blue? and the price is not in line with a good stone). You might want to read some in the knowledge section of this site about cut before proceeding. In addition, EGL is not known to be as accurate in grading as GIA and AGS, so you have to consider that the color or clarity might actually be lower than represented. We see this often.

A good way to search for an ideal cut diamond is to use the search tool below and put in excellent-excellent for cut and check GIA and AGS for labs (uncheck other).

https://www.pricescope.com/sift.aspx

 

[swingirl]

Are the first 4 Old European Cut stones?

You can do a comparison using PS''s Search by Cut or Price Comparison under the PRICES category.

 

[The3rdMan]

Thank you