Lightbox 1ct cushion, keep or return?

[jessicap]

I brought the 1ct blue cushion pendant from Lightbox in 50% off sale. Plan to mount it into a simple white gold mount to go with a white gold chain, which has special sentimental value for me. I want a blue stone since I already have a colorless round pendant, but this is my first cushion and don’t know if this is a good enough cut or not. I took some pictures of it next to my 0.6ct Brian Gavin ideal cut round pendant. The Lightbox cushion looks darker below the table but has more fire.

Should I keep it?

 

[Kim N]

Tagging tyty333 and lovedogs

 

[lovedogs]

I really cant tell anything about fancy cuts without video. Whether its good enough or not is completely up to you and whether you like it

 

[jessicap]

I really cant tell anything about fancy cuts without video. Whether its good enough or not is completely up to you and whether you like it

The video was taken indoor, next to a window

 

[Grymera]

If you're doubting it, I'd return it. Even at 50% off. There's always a great deal to be had when it comes to jewelry and it's a lot of money not to be over the moon thrilled with your diamond.

 

[MamaBee]

The video was taken indoor, next to a window

I think it’s beautiful..You have to love it..If you don’t then I would return it.

 

[jessicap]

I decided to return it. The more I looked at it, the more I was bothered by the lack of sparkles under the table.