shape
carat
color
clarity

LiW Is this weird?

shihtzulover

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Jun 30, 2010
Messages
717
Back in college, I had a serious boyfriend. We always talked about when we would get married - in the far future though, since my parents wanted me to graduate from college before getting married. On our one year anniversary, he gave me a promise ring.

The ring was actually one that I picked out, because I absolutely fell in love with it. He had a totally different ring in mind, but I found this one myself and showed it to him, explaining how much I liked it. It was simple - a princess cut solitaire (.10 carat) on a thin white gold band. I just loved princess cuts from the moment that I saw them, and I also really liked the thin band. I actually really think that he didn't want to get it, but he knew how much I loved it, so he agreed.

Even back then, I thought that when I did get engaged, I would want a three-stone princess cut engagement ring (just from seeing pictures online). The relationship with that boyfriend fell apart, and it was very messy, because it wasn't a clean break, and we tried to stay friends for a long time. I voluntarily gave the promise ring back to him because I didn't want it anymore - at the time, it just hurt too much to look at it.

Flash forward to when I met my FF (a few years after the breakup with my ex, a year since we had cut off all contact, and a few not-so-serious boyfriends later). When we started talking about getting engaged, I still thought that I wanted a three-stone princess cut ring. I looked around a lot, and I finally showed him a Tacori three-stone princess cut with diamonds around the band, since it was the most beautiful ring that I had ever seen (or so I thought, at least from the pictures of it online). We actually went to look at in person though, and I tried it on - and discovered that I didn't like it as much as I thought I did. I didn't even care for the other three-stone options that I tried on. Instead, I really loved the princess cut solitaires on the thin bands.

My FF and I finally chose our perfect ring: a beautiful 1.53 carat princess cut diamond on a thin platinum band. I love it so much and I think that it is classic and beautiful - but today I was thinking, will people think that it's weird that it might seem like it is just a much bigger and better version of the promise ring that my ex gave me? It really is the style that I find to be the most beautiful, and I can't picture having any other setting. I even tried solitaires with different types of small diamonds around the band, but I really like the plain platinum band, because I think it really makes the diamond stand out the most. Also, it makes sense to me that since I picked the same type of ring out years ago, I would still gravitate towards the same basic setting years later.

Do you think it's weird?
 
I wouldn't worry to much about it. You love the ring and in the end that's what matters. Some people's tastes change and someone people's dont and if that is the style you like than that's what you should be wearing. I think less people will draw a connection to your old promise ring than you think. Enjoy the ring, can't wait to hear about how your FF gives it to you!
 
Your taste in men changed... your taste in rings didn't. No biggie. Don't over analyze it.
 
Nah, I don't think that's weird. Solitaires are classic! Because of this, I definitely don't think it's weird that you'd be attracted to the same style now as you were then.
 
Nope, not weird. Honestly, I doubt many people would think twice about it. Those friends close enough to remember Version 1.0 know you well enough to know that you just love the style!
 
I don't think it's weird at all. You love what you love. And who would know that it's similar to your promise ring unless you told them? I wouldn't worry too much and just enjoy the beautiful ring and being engaged :) And congrats!
 
I wouldn't worry at all about it. In high school my ex gave me a promise ring, all I remember is that it was yellow gold and had 4 tiny diamonds, I have no idea what cut they were. I would say the general population of people don't know cuts of diamonds, heck people that work at maul stores don't even know :lol: !

I'm happy that you've found your favourite diamond cut and that there's no question about it. Your stone sounds like a real show stopper, I can't wait to see pics.
 
I don't think thats weird AT ALL. I highly highly doubt anybody will think that.
 
I don't think it's weird at all. You love solitaires -- no biggie! I also don't think anyone else would think it's odd.
 
Thanks everyone! You're all right - a solitaire is simple and classic, and I just love the look. Even if people did think it was weird, I don't think I could change settings, because I definitely love this one the most. Thanks for talking me out of my paranoia. :)
 
No I wouldn’t worry! I think it would be odd if anyone else even remembers exactly what your promise ring looked like :)

Most people don’t care about these things as much as ourselves.
 
NOPE! It's obviously something that is timeless and classy to you- and you still love the style all these years later. I don't think people will be fixated on the connection to your past- you like what you like, and that hasn't changed!
 
No I don't think it is weird. Your ex didn't choose the ring - you did.
Different story if he selected it all by himself etc. That might be a bit awkward.
 
I think you are probably the only person who remembers in detail what your promise ring looked like. Others probably will not or do not remember so I wouldn't worry about it.

As far as whether or not it's weird, no I don't think so. Your style is your style.
 
you love what you love, not because of your ex's influence. in fact, he had little to do with that promise ring-- it was all your choosing! so don't worry about it and love that ring (and Fi)!
 
Thanks ladies - you're right, it definitely was all my choosing. The promise ring that he showed me was totally different. So yeah, he never would have picked a princess cut one on his own. :)
 
Callisto said:
Your taste in men changed... your taste in rings didn't. No biggie. Don't over analyze it.

Bingo. People have better things to worry about than thinking "Oh hey, isn't that like the promise ring she got all those years ago?" No one else will notice or care.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top