Is this eternity band a good size?

[appreciateyouradvice]

E-ring: 1.76 cushion, band is approx 1.7mm
Eternity band: 8.5 pointers, actual setting will be lower than this one as I want them set in a low basket.
Ring size: 4.75

I will wear a knife edge spacer band between the two rings, as seen in the pics.

What do you think? Is 8.5 points the right size? I was going to go with 10 pointers but was worried it would swallow my cushion.

Thanks!

 

[Enerchi]

IMO, I think this is a bit larger than what I would want the proportion to be in regards to my ering. It is a STUNNINGLY GORGEOUS eternity band - no doubt about that! - but when worn together (as you intend to do) it seems a bit large. Did you try on some .5's? How did they look? You have such a beautiful solitaire , I'd hate to see it be overwhelmed

but it sure looks PURRRRDY on your hand !

 

[purplesilk]

8.5 pointers diamonds make a gorgeous stand alone band...for a balanced look with your e-ring, I'd choose an eternity band with 2 or 3 pointers...

 

[elliemay]

I agree with the previous posters -- it's a beautiful ring and would be perfect by itself, but I think it's a bit big to go beside your e-ring. I'd second a vote for 2-3 pointers...or maybe 4?

All personal preference, though, so if you absolutely love it, go for it!

 

[motownmama]

Wondering if you've tried on a band that just about matches the shank on your ER - I'd love to see how that looks! Your ER is TDF and while I love bling, the band you show WAY overwhelms your gorgeous ring IMHO.

 

[ame]

Personally I think a band that's the same width as the band in your ering would be more appropriate. A big eternity band like that makes your ering look WAY smaller and less fabulous.

 

[mrssalvo]

I agree with the others, the 8.5's are a great stand alone band but I'd go smaller with your e-ring (which is beautiful btw)

 

[yssie]

Another vote for smaller if you're going to wear them together. Your Ering is lovely

 

[violet3]

If you are planning on wearing them together, the band is way too big for your ering - it completely overwhelms it and makes it look small. I saw the specs on it, so I know it's not small at all! I would go much smaller - for reference, how big are the stones in the band of your ering?

 

[Diamond*Dana]

Another vote for a smaller eternity ring to go with your gorgeous e-ring!