Input on a 1.5 carat round

[jrtill]

Does anyone have an opinion on this stone?

http://www.bluenile.com/round-diamo...ty_LD03386634?keyword_search_value=LD03386634

HCA score was 1.6. Fire & Spread were excellent, Light Return and Scintillation were very good. Blue Nile said from a visual inspection it was eye clean and didn't have any negative effects from the fluorescence. I am a little concerned about the table size, crown angle and crown height. She wants something that will face up as big as possible but still have excellent fire and brilliance.

Thanks

 

[diamondseeker2006]

A 60/60 stone is going to be a bright/white stone but won't have as much fire as a stone with a smaller table and higher crown. I personally prefer a smaller table, but that preference has developed after seeing a number of ideal cut diamonds. But there is nothing wrong with a diamond with a 60 table if that is what someone prefers. Table size has nothing to do with the size appearance of the diamond. It is the diameter measurements that you compare to determine that. Fluorescence is a huge plus in a J color stone and I would prefer that it had it.