I''ll let you guys decide?

[BlueEyes]

The shopping continues, here are the details,

GIA Certified
Round Brilliant
I Color
SI1 Clarity
8.33 x 8.45 x 4.95mm
No Culet
Faint Fluor.
Girdle - Very thin - thin
Depth - 59.0
Table - 59.0
Polish - Good
Symmetry - Good

Please let me know your thoughts. Thanks.

 

[Regular Guy]

Blue Eyes,

This 60/60 page in the tutorial tries to provide the logic of why more info is needed to make an appropriately educated guess. Round here, that means either or both crown & pavilion data, or reflector visual images.

 

[Demelza]

Not really enough info to say much. It''s not an ideal cut as I''m sure you know. And the very thin girdle might be a concern -- it kind of depends how big an area is considered very thin and how you''re going to set it. If it''s going in a bezel, then it doesn''t matter much. In a stone this size, I would prefer that polish and certainly symmetry be better than "good". The stones PhoenixGirl posted yesterday looked great. Would you consider any of those?