I have 2 GIA Reports, need help reading them!!??

[mrsj8610]

Insurance found me 2 replacement diamonds and sent me the GIA reports on both. The cut isn't listed so I have no clue which one is the better of the two? HELP which one is better on paper? They are both Oval brilliants, .90, VVS2, one I color and one F color. They both have flourescence. I just have no clue! One measures up bigger, but I want the one that will be more beautiful! I appreciate all the help I can get!

 

[06pvc]

There is not that much information to be taken from non-round reports.

 

[Christina...]

can you ask that the stones be sent to an independent appraiser for evaluation? You need much more information than the reports can supply you. I would ask them to get an ASET image of the stones for you and then post them here, if they won't allow you have them sent to an appraiser, though I'm not sure why the wouldn't.