Help with 6 different RBs

[MusicCity]

Hi everyone,
My saga searching for a stone is coming to a close. I've showed my gf some great bling that's been posted here and she's now solidly in the round brilliant camp with a cushion halo. I blame this _gorgeous_ ring! https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/victor-canera-cushion-halo-engagement-ring.224202/
I spoke with Victor Canera and he sent 6 stones from his inventory over for me to check out. I'm really digging the 1.7 I VS2 but I was hoping to draw on the wealth of knowledge here. Hopefully the links posted below work. Thanks everyone!

http://bit.ly/2u0Fdzy
http://bit.ly/2uE7ptM
http://bit.ly/2eQ18Yi
http://bit.ly/2tLgoMH
http://bit.ly/2uEkzHo
http://bit.ly/2tLwaqN

 

[Queenie60]

All of these stones are ideal. I would go with the I 1.7. More bang for your buck. I'm most positive that a well cut I will sparkle like crazy. Maybe the experts can chime in as I'm going on common sense alone!

 

[flyingpig]

I personally think this particular design works well with bigger stones. so 1.7c I VS2

 

[SimoneDi]

+ another vote for the 1.7 I VS2! I think that the stone will look amazing in Emilya cushion halo!

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Almost all responses here will be to get the 1.7 if putting in a halo, especially. The size is noticeably larger than the others.

I am so glad you showed her rings and found out what she really likes! If only everyone would do that!!!

 

[ac117]

I agree with you and with everyone above in choosing the 1.7 I VS2! Great size, eye clean, nice price. The cushion halo will cover tint from the side. If I had to choose a second, it would be the 1.500 G SI1.

 

[MusicCity]

Thanks everyone! I'm attempting to get the ASET sent over just to confirm and I will put that beauty on hold.
My only concern would be the color set against the melee. It seems like most PSers are ok with near-colorless so perhaps my concerns are misguided.

 

[ac117]

The ASET is provided in the same link and looks great (3rd down from the video). With an I color, there won't be such a dramatic contrast. Melee sparkles differently since they are so small, which also helps.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Yeah, the ASET is right there on the page with the stone. Victor only chooses round brilliants that have excellent ASET images, anyway. We have people here with J color and probably even lower in Victor's halos.