Hi guys,
I have narrowed my choice down to 2 diamonds from 2 different stores with a price difference of $300, so it's pretty irrelevant. However I don't know which the better diamond is as I can't see them side by side! They both have their positives, one is hearts and arrows si1, but the inclusion is on the table, the other is si2 with inclusion closer to the edge, but has a new GIA certificate dated April this year, where as the other one is 2 years old which makes me wonder why no one else has bought this diamond - what do they see that I have missed? Both return under 2 on the HCA tool, the H&A is under 1 and is ex ex ex vg, where as the si2 is ex ex vg ex. Anyway, I have attached both reports, please give me your feed back and why. I will be putting a deposit on one or the other tomorrow morning. Thank you!
Ps, both appear to be eye clean is the shop.
Thank you!


I have narrowed my choice down to 2 diamonds from 2 different stores with a price difference of $300, so it's pretty irrelevant. However I don't know which the better diamond is as I can't see them side by side! They both have their positives, one is hearts and arrows si1, but the inclusion is on the table, the other is si2 with inclusion closer to the edge, but has a new GIA certificate dated April this year, where as the other one is 2 years old which makes me wonder why no one else has bought this diamond - what do they see that I have missed? Both return under 2 on the HCA tool, the H&A is under 1 and is ex ex ex vg, where as the si2 is ex ex vg ex. Anyway, I have attached both reports, please give me your feed back and why. I will be putting a deposit on one or the other tomorrow morning. Thank you!
Ps, both appear to be eye clean is the shop.
Thank you!

