Help!!! Which diamond?

[devondoo]

Good morning,

I'm wondering what diamond everyone would go with... here is the options the jeweller gave me, price includes the mount which is Canadian 18k gold and .05 Canadian diamonds, sizing, maintenance and setting. (Please note I am in Canada... our dollar is low and therefore it may seem a bit pricier than those in the US)
Also, will there be ANY difference in size by the naked eye?

Princess cut-
Canadian diamond .7 H VVSI very good cut GIA cert $4875
Non-canadian diamond .81 D SI1 good cut GIA cert $4950
Non-candian diamond .72 F SI1 good cut GIA cert $4070
Non-canadian diamond .76 H VS2 good cut GIA cert $4495
Non-canadian diamond .73 F SI2 good cut GIA cert $3999

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I am sorry but we would have to have a lot more information to advise you on those stones, and first and foremost, magnified images of the stones. We can't tell you about the size differences without the measurements of all the stones. All I can do is show you what ideal cut princess cuts look like, and maybe that will help you narrow down the best ones. GIA does not grade princess cuts as excellent or very good, so someone else is assigning those categories. I would only look at ones that were considered excellent/ideal cut.

Examples of ideal cut princess cuts:

http://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/princess-cut-loose-diamond-3022036.htm

http://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/princess-cut-loose-diamond-3189831.htm

I am not sure about exchange rates, but it appears to me you might get better quality for the same or even lower price by buying stones like these in the US. A simple solitaire setting is around $350-500 in gold.

 

[devondoo]

Here are the GIA certs.