Find your diamond
Find your jewelry
shape
carat
color
clarity

Help select between these idealscopes!

R

readingbabelfish

Rough_Rock
Joined
May 10, 2013
Messages
13
In order,

#1 123661
#2 173943
#3 174233
#4 182581









These are for a set of studs. Please let me know what you guys think!

Thanks a lot!!

173943_is.jpg

123661_is.jpg

174233_is.jpg

182581_is.jpg
 
I believe it may help you if you post additional info on each one. If you have copies of the labs reports or specs of each etc.
 
2 & 3
 
There is absolutely no question, #1 has the superior ideal scope image. without knowing anything else and assuming its eye clean, that's the clear winner. Can you post the #'s? Like the depth %, table %, crown and pavillion angles?
 
For starters, these diamonds are all candidates for a set of studs. I have them all on hold with JamesAllen.com. I do not have the specs as they are on hold. I picked them out and had a gemologist at JamesAllen look at them and send me the idealscopes. They should be getting back to me with all the specs. I know that I picked them out and the specs were decent. The gemologist recommended #1 and #4. They said that was the best match. As I have these on hold for 24 hours only, I will post specs as soon as they get back to me. I will need immediate help after I do so! Thank you all for looking at them and the replies.
 
04diamond<3|1369107522|3450950 said:
There is absolutely no question, #1 has the superior ideal scope image. without knowing anything else and assuming its eye clean, that's the clear winner. Can you post the #'s? Like the depth %, table %, crown and pavillion angles?
Click to expand...

2nd completely - lovely arrows too!
 
readingbabelfish|1369132345|3451027 said:
For starters, these diamonds are all candidates for a set of studs. I have them all on hold with JamesAllen.com. I do not have the specs as they are on hold. I picked them out and had a gemologist at JamesAllen look at them and send me the idealscopes. They should be getting back to me with all the specs. I know that I picked them out and the specs were decent. The gemologist recommended #1 and #4. They said that was the best match. As I have these on hold for 24 hours only, I will post specs as soon as they get back to me. I will need immediate help after I do so! Thank you all for looking at them and the replies.
Click to expand...

Can they recommend one that matches #1 better, more closely?
 
 
04diamond<3 said:
I found this one after clicking #1 and seeing their similar diamonds suggestions. Here's one that I found:

http://www.jamesallen.com/loose-diamonds/round-cut/0.40-carat-h-color-i1-clarity-excellent-cut-sku-40918

Does it fit in your budget? Can you get an idealscope on it? I feel like it matches the arrows on #1 better and it's closer to size..
Click to expand...

It definitely looks good! It does fit into budget. I will have to ask if I can get another idealscope done on that one! I think that #1 looks pretty good. I will post back as soon as I find some more info! Thank you!
 
I ended up going with #1 and #4. I talked to the people at JamesAllen.com about checking out the above mentioned stone, and the gemologist assured me that the match they recommended was a great match. Both are eyeclean and look very nice together. I also have 60 days of inspection time where if I don't like anything for any reason, I can return it with shipping paid by them. I ordered #1 and #4 with a 4 prong 18k white gold setting. I will post some pics when I get the setup!
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Jewelry Blog
PriceScope-Concierge-Ad
Find prime cuts.
Top