Find your diamond
Find your jewelry
shape
carat
color
clarity

Help please with HCA

C

chandler1417

Rough_Rock
Joined
Nov 8, 2022
Messages
20
Hi, I want to purchase a 3.05ct round hearts & arrows diamond. I used the HCA an everything came back excellent except for “spread” which is very good. The rating is a 0.9. Pls see HAC report
Light Return:

1672717997379.png

Because, the HCA is 0.9 instead of 1.0, is it ok to purchase?
 
Hello and welcome to PriceScope, chandler1417!
If all is well with the cut quality and optical performance, then absolutely a 0.9 score is fine.

"Very Good" in spread merely means that the actual measured diameter falls within the expected calculated diameter range.
Looks Like size = Big
..."Average" is A-OK, as that's what would be the norm for a *majority* of very well proportioned diamonds of the same carat weight. Yours is "Big" merely because the actual measurements equate to a slightly bigger physical diameter/spread. Again, A-OK as long as the optics check out.
 
Are you buying on-line? Do you have a link to this stone? Any video? Put the stone on-hold first.
 
tyty333 said:
Are you buying on-line? Do you have a link to this stone? Any video? Put the stone on-hold first.
Click to expand...

+1 to this. We'd need to see a magnified video and preferably also an ASET image to advise further. 0.9 is perfectly fine for an HCA score.
 
tyty333 said:
Are you buying on-line? Do you have a link to this stone? Any video? Put the stone on-hold first.
Click to expand...
First, I would like to say thank you for responding. I am buying the stone online and since it is an “exchange”, I won’t be able to return. I Will try to include the link .

chandler1417 said:
First, I would like to say thank you for responding. I am buying the stone online and since it is an “exchange”, I won’t be able to return. I Will try to include the link .

Click to expand...
 
DejaWiz said:
Hello and welcome to PriceScope, chandler1417!
If all is well with the cut quality and optical performance, then absolutely a 0.9 score is fine.

"Very Good" in spread merely means that the actual measured diameter falls within the expected calculated diameter range.
Looks Like size = Big
..."Average" is A-OK, as that's what would be the norm for a *majority* of very well proportioned diamonds of the same carat weight. Yours is "Big" merely because the actual measurements equate to a slightly bigger physical diameter/spread. Again, A-OK as long as the optics check out.
Click to expand...

Thank you for getting back to me. Is there anyway you can check out the video and let me know if it’s ok to purchase?

DejaWiz said:
Hello and welcome to PriceScope, chandler1417!
If all is well with the cut quality and optical performance, then absolutely a 0.9 score is fine.

"Very Good" in spread merely means that the actual measured diameter falls within the expected calculated diameter range.
Looks Like size = Big
..."Average" is A-OK, as that's what would be the norm for a *majority* of very well proportioned diamonds of the same carat weight. Yours is "Big" merely because the actual measurements equate to a slightly bigger physical diameter/spread. Again, A-OK as long as the optics check out.
Click to expand...

Shop Certified Loose Diamonds Online - Friendly Diamonds

At Friendly Diamond, find the perfect certified loose diamonds in a variety of shapes, colors, clarities, carat weights and lab grown options.
friendlydiamonds.com friendlydiamonds.com
 
chandler1417 said:
First, I would like to say thank you for responding. I am buying the stone online and since it is an “exchange”, I won’t be able to return. I Will try to include the link .

Click to expand...

Shop Certified Loose Diamonds Online - Friendly Diamonds

At Friendly Diamond, find the perfect certified loose diamonds in a variety of shapes, colors, clarities, carat weights and lab grown options.
friendlydiamonds.com friendlydiamonds.com
 
Kim N said:
Although it looks decently cut, I recommend sticking with GIA or AGS for natural diamonds. IGI can be softer on color and clarity, so you may not be getting a true G VS1 for the price.
Click to expand...

Ok thanks
 
Kim N said:
Oops, somehow I missed that. I think it looks great, and the price is excellent.
Click to expand...

Do you think it’s ok even though HCA rated it a 0.9?
 
chandler1417 said:
Do you think it’s ok even though HCA rated it a 0.9?
Click to expand...

HCA of 0.9 is not a problem at all. As long as it's under 2 or sometimes 2.5, it's worth further consideration.
 
psadmin please move thread to MMD/LGD subforum.

chandler1417 I also think it looks good, especially for the 40.9/33.6/56 combo.
It does have some light CVD graining, has a pinkish-brown hue, and some minor pavilion twist...just wanted you to be aware.
 
Kim N said:
What do you think of this one?

Shop Certified Loose Diamonds Online - Friendly Diamonds

At Friendly Diamond, find the perfect certified loose diamonds in a variety of shapes, colors, clarities, carat weights and lab grown options.
friendlydiamonds.com friendlydiamonds.com
Click to expand...

That is very nice, I wanted to stay under $2700, but I may consider. By the way, what do you think of this one?
https://friendlydiamonds.com/lab-diamonds/view/round-3.28-g-vs1-ideal-206871
By, the way thanks for your assistance.
 
Ok thank you for looking
 
DejaWiz said:
Hello and welcome to PriceScope, chandler1417!
If all is well with the cut quality and optical performance, then absolutely a 0.9 score is fine.

"Very Good" in spread merely means that the actual measured diameter falls within the expected calculated diameter range.
Looks Like size = Big
..."Average" is A-OK, as that's what would be the norm for a *majority* of very well proportioned diamonds of the same carat weight. Yours is "Big" merely because the actual measurements equate to a slightly bigger physical diameter/spread. Again, A-OK as long as the optics check out.
Click to expand...

Thanks for the feedback. Can you check out the actual diamond and tell me what you think?

Shop Certified Loose Diamonds Online - Friendly Diamonds

At Friendly Diamond, find the perfect certified loose diamonds in a variety of shapes, colors, clarities, carat weights and lab grown options.
friendlydiamonds.com friendlydiamonds.com
 
chandler1417 said:
Thanks for the feedback. Can you check out the actual diamond and tell me what you think?

Shop Certified Loose Diamonds Online - Friendly Diamonds

At Friendly Diamond, find the perfect certified loose diamonds in a variety of shapes, colors, clarities, carat weights and lab grown options.
friendlydiamonds.com friendlydiamonds.com
Click to expand...

He did. :))

DejaWiz said:
chandler1417 I also think it looks good, especially for the 40.9/33.6/56 combo.
It does have some light CVD graining, has a pinkish-brown hue, and some minor pavilion twist...just wanted you to be aware.
Click to expand...
 
DejaWiz said:
Hello and welcome to PriceScope, chandler1417!
If all is well with the cut quality and optical performance, then absolutely a 0.9 score is fine.

"Very Good" in spread merely means that the actual measured diameter falls within the expected calculated diameter range.
Looks Like size = Big
..."Average" is A-OK, as that's what would be the norm for a *majority* of very well proportioned diamonds of the same carat weight. Yours is "Big" merely because the actual measurements equate to a slightly bigger physical diameter/spread. Again, A-OK as long as the optics check out.
Click to expand...

Thanks for the feedback. Can you check out the actual diamond and tell me what you think?

DejaWiz said:
psadmin please move thread to MMD/LGD subforum.

chandler1417 I also think it looks good, especially for the 40.9/33.6/56 combo.
It does have some light CVD graining, has a pinkish-brown hue, and some minor pavilion twist...just wanted you to be aware.
Click to expand...

DejaWiz,
Sorry to bother you again. I have another question for you? Do you think the diamond will have any leakage or not sparkle? Also will the diamond face up 3ct?
 
chandler1417 said:
Thanks for the feedback. Can you check out the actual diamond and tell me what you think?



DejaWiz,
Sorry to bother you again. I have another question for you? Do you think the diamond will have any leakage or not sparkle? Also will the diamond face up 3ct?
Click to expand...

Here are my thoughts on it, from my previous comment:

Help please with HCA

Hi, I want to purchase a 3.05ct round hearts & arrows diamond. I used the HCA an everything came back excellent except for “spread” which is very good. The rating is a 0.9. Pls see HAC report Light Return: Because, the HCA is 0.9 instead of 1.0, is it ok to purchase?
www.pricescope.com

There may be some slight leakages (circled areas below), but only an ASET or Ideal-Scope can definitively reveal any impact.
It absolutely faces up at 3ct since the diameter is 9.35-9.39mm.
Friendly Diamonds has both a return policy and an LGD trade-in/upgrade program, so if this diamond has captured your attention, then it may be worth buying it so that you can see it in hand with your own eyes.

Screenshot_20230104-064713-048.png

Return Policy - Friendly Diamonds

We offer complimentary free return shipping for all returns from within the United States.
friendlydiamonds.com friendlydiamonds.com

Our Customer Services | Friendly Diamonds

At Friendly Diamonds, we provide the highest level of customer service and are reachable via email, phone, or live chat on the website
friendlydiamonds.com friendlydiamonds.com
 
DejaWiz said:
Here are my thoughts on it, from my previous comment:

Help please with HCA

Hi, I want to purchase a 3.05ct round hearts & arrows diamond. I used the HCA an everything came back excellent except for “spread” which is very good. The rating is a 0.9. Pls see HAC report Light Return: Because, the HCA is 0.9 instead of 1.0, is it ok to purchase?
www.pricescope.com

There may be some slight leakages (circled areas below), but only an ASET or Ideal-Scope can definitively reveal any impact.
It absolutely faces up at 3ct since the diameter is 9.35-9.39mm.
Friendly Diamonds has both a return policy and an LGD trade-in/upgrade program, so if this diamond has captured your attention, then it may be worth buying it so that you can see it in hand with your own eyes.

Screenshot_20230104-064713-048.png

Return Policy - Friendly Diamonds

We offer complimentary free return shipping for all returns from within the United States.
friendlydiamonds.com friendlydiamonds.com

Our Customer Services | Friendly Diamonds

At Friendly Diamonds, we provide the highest level of customer service and are reachable via email, phone, or live chat on the website
friendlydiamonds.com friendlydiamonds.com
Click to expand...

Thanks again. I’m aware of their return-policy. As for my situation, I’m returning a ring and going up a ct size. Because of this, whatever diamond I pick, I’m stuck with. Therefore I’m panicking, I’m trying to pick the best diamond.

If you can assist me one more time in reviewing the HCA and video, I will greatly appreciated.


1672888062094.png1672888062094.pngC929EDC4-94D7-4685-B7E0-6C47B716D2D9.pngC929EDC4-94D7-4685-B7E0-6C47B716D2D9.png
 

Attachments

  • 66C1BB6D-EF0B-4A50-BE02-5985716B5279.png
    66C1BB6D-EF0B-4A50-BE02-5985716B5279.png
    343.7 KB · Views: 4
chandler1417 said:
Thanks again. I’m aware of their return-policy. As for my situation, I’m returning a ring and going up a ct size. Because of this, whatever diamond I pick, I’m stuck with. Therefore I’m panicking, I’m trying to pick the best diamond.

If you can assist me one more time in reviewing the HCA and video, I will greatly appreciated.


1672888062094.png1672888062094.pngC929EDC4-94D7-4685-B7E0-6C47B716D2D9.pngC929EDC4-94D7-4685-B7E0-6C47B716D2D9.png
Click to expand...
file:///var/mobile/Library/SMS/Attachments/a9/09/1936668D-C37F-4AD4-843E-57F2841DC2BF/M85568.mp4
 
chandler1417 said:
Thanks again. I’m aware of their return-policy. As for my situation, I’m returning a ring and going up a ct size. Because of this, whatever diamond I pick, I’m stuck with. Therefore I’m panicking, I’m trying to pick the best diamond.

If you can assist me one more time in reviewing the HCA and video, I will greatly appreciated.


1672888062094.png1672888062094.pngC929EDC4-94D7-4685-B7E0-6C47B716D2D9.pngC929EDC4-94D7-4685-B7E0-6C47B716D2D9.png
Click to expand...

What is your max budget and min carat weight desired? I will search Friendly Diamonds site to see what I can find.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP

Featured Topics

Jewelry Blog
PriceScope-Concierge-Ad
Find prime cuts.
Top