Help me please!! 2 1.5ct stones - compare them -

[Vic8870]

1) AGS1 I SI1
C-35.3, P-40.6, T-55.1, 52/78
Light Performance 0
Polish 0
Symmetry 1
No Fluor
HCA 1.2 TIC

2) AGS0 I VS2
C-34.9, P-41.1, T-56.5, 52/78
Light Performance 0
Polish 0
Symmetry 0
Med Blue Fluor
HCA 3!!

Compter generated images from the reports attached, 1st image for stone 1.
I like the fluor and VS2 of the second stone better, but does that HCA mean it won''t be as sparkly/fiery as the first?

Thanks for your help!!

 

[stone-cold11]

I prefer #1.

 

[Lorelei]

The first has safer numbers.