Help me pick between these 2 settings.

[dhimer]

Ladies I need help. I feel so indecisive. I thought I was all ready to go with my setting and then I came agreed a scholdt setting that I also fell in love with. So now I have 2 loves and can’t pick myself. Hence I’m turning to you my tribe. Note both rings will be in 2 tone and will have a different band then what is shown here. I wanted a ring that’s both modern and has some vintage elements.

Option 1) this DK ring.

I love the ring but wonder if it will make the stone appear smaller ?
Option 2 - this ring without the side stones
( see link for video )

Login • Instagram

Welcome back to Instagram. Sign in to check out what your friends, family & interests have been capturing & sharing around the world.

www.instagram.com

And here is a side by side

So which one ?

 

[caf]

Two different looks. Both are beautiful. I love #1. I like #2.

I think #1 is classic, elegant and so wearable. I don’t think you’ll tire of #1. You might with #2.

 

[lurkie91]

I agree that both are beautiful. I think it really comes down to your style, #1 to me is softer, more feminine and subtle whereas #2 is bolder and more of a statement ring.

Personally, I would pick #1 as I find it more wearable. I don't think the claw prongs on #1 will make your stone look smaller than it is, but I do think that #2 will give the illusion of a bigger stone.

 

[MRBXXXFVVS1]

#2

 

[lillibear]

Is this a right hand ring?

 

[dhimer]

Is this a right hand ring?

It’s not an engagement ring. Just another ring I’m buying myself. I may wear it instead of my ering sometimes but most often a right hand ring

 

[JPie]

I prefer 1 for its more delicate look.

 

[LoveMeDo]

I’d vote 2 for a right hand ring. Love it!

 

[lillibear]

I vote for 2 for a RHR; although they are both lovely

 

[tyty333]

I really like number 1 but for a right-hand ring I think I'm going to have to vote
number 2. If it were for an engagement ring I would vote number 1.

Both pretty!