shape
carat
color
clarity

Help me find a engagement stone/setting?

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

doctorbonez

Rough_Rock
Joined
Jul 26, 2007
Messages
13
I'm looking for an engagement ring in the near future and have done a little searching, but I'm not really sure if what I've found thus far is good or not.

My gf has her eye on a 3 stone ring with a princess center and pears on the side. I can't really afford much (3.5k-4k) so I'm pretty limited. Although she said that size doesnt matter, i think she really wants to break the 1ct barrier (which i realize is impossible if I include a 3 stone setting), thus I've been looking more in the .85ct range (hard to come by since it sits right between two 1/4 carat increments). From my research/understanding, here are the specs I've been looking for

Carats: ~.8-.9
Cut: Very good and above (trying to stay with Table between 65-75% and depth between 60-72)
Color: I and above (I realize princesses show color better, but we saw a couple of I's and I think we can deal with an I color on a princess), although H would be ideal
Clarity: SI1 and above

The material of the ring isn't that important, but I was hoping to find something in white gold so I can save some money since she doesnt seem to have any preference one way or another.

Currently I've picked out a .84 ct w/ very good cut, I color, VS1 clarity, Depth 72.8, Table 64%, thin-med girdle, VG symmetry, Excellent polish for around $2300 on blue nile, with a 3 stone setting in platinum with 2 pear side stones (1/4 tcw) for around $1500 (a bit more than Id like to spend, seeing hte stone is only 2300).. so the total is around 3800.

Anyone out there with suggestions on better stones/rings?

btw. I have some contacts (not very close.. more like friends relative with employee discount/ dad's client) in the diamond industry.. but I wonder if they will be able to come close to BN in price? Ive checked out some of their stock, but haven't really talked price yet (not quite sure how to 'ask for a discount' at this point). Do you think these avenues are worth pursuing? (they are all atleast 1hr away from me and I really can't get out there except for weekends)
 
Welcome to PS! First of all, PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE don''t buy from a "friend" in the industry. So many people have been burned on here by so called "friends". Secondly, check out Whiteflash. Their ACA princesses are a top notch cut, and a top cut will make it really sparkle, AND thus it will look bigger than a more poorly cut stone because it reflects more light.
 
The sides stones are always going to increase the price of a setting greatly. I''d suggest using most of your budget towards a quality center stone and then maybe reset on an anniversary into the setting with the sidestones when you have a little more time to save and maybe a bit more to work into the budget. I agree with neatfreak that the Whiteflash ACA princess stone''s are amazing, also check our GoodoldGold.com and Wink Jones of Winfields for princess stone''s in your budget.
 

I too will soon be in the market for a ring. My girlfriend has subtlety mentioned cushion cut and really liking Tiffany''s Legacy. When doing some research I found this sight and MsSalvo''s posting from a couple years ago and really love the Tiffany repruduction you posted then. I have attached it below.


I have tried to track down the Quest jeweler who made this for you and haven''t been successful. Any help would be greatly appreciated.


I live in Atlanta. Should I take this picture to a couple of jewelers and ask what they have to say?


mssalvoring.jpg
 
Date: 7/29/2007 11:07:30 PM
Author: justclueless

I too will soon be in the market for a ring. My girlfriend has subtlety mentioned cushion cut and really liking Tiffany''s Legacy. When doing some research I found this sight and MsSalvo''s posting from a couple years ago and really love the Tiffany repruduction you posted then. I have attached it below.



I have tried to track down the Quest jeweler who made this for you and haven''t been successful. Any help would be greatly appreciated.



I live in Atlanta. Should I take this picture to a couple of jewelers and ask what they have to say?
Hi! you should start a new thread for these questions to get more responses
 
Date: 7/29/2007 9:38:41 PM
Author: mrssalvo
The sides stones are always going to increase the price of a setting greatly. I''d suggest using most of your budget towards a quality center stone and then maybe reset on an anniversary into the setting with the sidestones when you have a little more time to save and maybe a bit more to work into the budget. I agree with neatfreak that the Whiteflash ACA princess stone''s are amazing, also check our GoodoldGold.com and Wink Jones of Winfields for princess stone''s in your budget.
Ditto. Just stick with AGS0 Princess and you should do well.
 
Thanks for everyone's ideas, especially the White gold pear setting for 950$! What do you think of 2x .25 carats on the sides if the center stone will only be .8-1 carat? Will the ratios look alittle off? (how many times do u hear about someone saying that a diamond is TOO big?.. lol)

What is the collective thoughts on this stone?

http://www.jamesallen.com/diamonds/I-SI1-Premium-Cut-Princess-Diamond-1063227.asp
 
Date: 7/30/2007 5:28:44 PM
Author: doctorbonez
Thanks for everyone''s ideas, especially the White gold pear setting for 950$! What do you think of 2x .25 carats on the sides if the center stone will only be .8-1 carat? Will the ratios look alittle off? (how many times do u hear about someone saying that a diamond is TOO big?.. lol)

What is the collective thoughts on this stone?

http://www.jamesallen.com/diamonds/I-SI1-Premium-Cut-Princess-Diamond-1063227.asp

Hi again. I''m so bad with princess cuts so I''m not sure I can help with that stone. Most people here will tell you to go with AGS because they can grade princess cuts on light performance so it is easier for the buyer to pick a winner. I wanted to tell you that I have a 1.28 center stone with .25 carat pear sides and it looks amazing (in my opinion!). If you look on my topics started you can find my pics. i think the same setting would look great with a 1 carat center
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top