Help me decide what is best

[rookieb]

I am looking for a diamond for my lady. I cannot decide what is best. I have three stones with different quality. Can someone tell whats best among the three? All of them are princess cuts. Please rate them relative to each other.

Stone1 :
1.02CT
E
VS1
Table : 74
Depth : 69.8
5.7*5.53*3.86
$4650
medium girdle

Stone2 :
.85CT
H
VS2
Table : 60
Depth : 65
Medium girdle
5.65*5.42*3.51
crown height : 11.8
stone 3 :
$4300

.91
VS2
H
T 71
D 77.4
Slightly thick to thick
5.19*5.17*4.00
$3250

The dealers did not provide the crown height/pavillion details for stones 1/3.

Which one has the best value? Also tell me the value ranking for all.

Your suggestions will be greatly appreciated.

 

[moremoremore]

WOW. #3 is WAY deep. Forget about it. #1 is a bit deep but table looks good. #2 looks like a very small table, but superbcert has lots of tables smaller than that. #2 looks like a good crown, BUT, that's a EGL cert, right? I HATE egl b/c I had an "H" that was a bad "I" in actuality. ALso, you just can't tell from the #s in princess cuts...#1 looks a tad deep, but I would pick that one...by the numbers and b/c it's an E. Then again, I'd keep looking for a G Vs2-Si1 if it were me!

 

[rookieb]

Thank you for your reply sir.how about this?
CT 1.04
G
VS2
Depth 71.9%
Table 68%
Girdle med-vtk
5.52x5.51x3.96
$4242