Help me decide between 2 setting designs!

[Hara]

Good rainy morning to everyone!

We are designing our our ring and the jewler just sent me 2 designs of the same ring.... I always wanted the north south east west center prong setting which makes the diamond (round 1.06 ct) look more round.... but I also like the traditional setting which end up looking more square. I also like the fact that the n/s/e/w adds some solidity to the 2 prongs on the side as the cathedral is welded to them.... but I can''t decide on the look, and I wanted some opinions....

here are the photos:

 

[Hara]

And this:

 

[Hara]

And this:

 

[geckodani]

I love the NS orientation! It''s a unique twist and a lot of fun, IMO.

 

[Ice Scream]

I like option A for one reason: When you are wearing the ring, you will mostly only see diamond from your point of view. I think this is the main reason for using a 4 prong setting. You get to see more of the diamond.

If you want the diamond to look more round, why not just get a six prong setting. I actually prefer the six prong, but if you are going to go for four prong, I would stick with option A.

 

[Hara]

Hmm Ice, I actually thought I would see more diamond from my point of view with option B, because when I look at my own hand it is always slanted a little diagonnally inward (such as when I type, eat, or write), it is rare that I have my hand straight forward perpendicularly to my body so that I can look at it straight on.... I figured that the North South allows me to see diamond from 4 angles, as opposed to 2 in option A due to the cathedral blocking the views from the 2 sides.... That''s why i would never get 6 prongs, its so pretty but its only good for a much larger diamond that mine.... ANy thoughts? Am I totally out to lunch?

 

[geckodani]

Date: 6/9/2009 10:34:27 AM
Author: Hara
Hmm Ice, I actually thought I would see more diamond from my point of view with option B, because when I look at my own hand it is always slanted a little diagonnally inward (such as when I type, eat, or write), it is rare that I have my hand straight forward perpendicularly to my body so that I can look at it straight on.... I figured that the North South allows me to see diamond from 4 angles, as opposed to 2 in option A due to the cathedral blocking the views from the 2 sides.... That''s why i would never get 6 prongs, its so pretty but its only good for a much larger diamond that mine.... ANy thoughts? Am I totally out to lunch?

LOL - good point. Rarely do we hold our hands completely perpendicular to our bodies!

 

[Ice Scream]

I guess you''re right. You would probably know better than me how women view their rings on a daily basis (with me being a man who never wears rings and all).

Go with your first instict. I have come to learn that it is usually right. Either way, I think the ring will look beautiful.

 

[Hara]

Thank you, glad you like the designs.... any other thoughts on the rest of the setting...overall look, common prong setting, sidestones (10 x.05), any other details... ?

 

[Hara]

Date: 6/9/2009 10:37:59 AM
Author: geckodani

Date: 6/9/2009 10:34:27 AM
Author: Hara
Hmm Ice, I actually thought I would see more diamond from my point of view with option B, because when I look at my own hand it is always slanted a little diagonnally inward (such as when I type, eat, or write), it is rare that I have my hand straight forward perpendicularly to my body so that I can look at it straight on.... I figured that the North South allows me to see diamond from 4 angles, as opposed to 2 in option A due to the cathedral blocking the views from the 2 sides.... That''s why i would never get 6 prongs, its so pretty but its only good for a much larger diamond that mine.... ANy thoughts? Am I totally out to lunch?

LOL - good point. Rarely do we hold our hands completely perpendicular to our bodies!

It''s true though, lol! Unless we are looking at our nails.... lol

 

[D&T]

Date: 6/9/2009 10:15:27 AM
Author:Hara
Good rainy morning to everyone!

We are designing our our ring and the jewler just sent me 2 designs of the same ring.... I always wanted the north south east west center prong setting which makes the diamond (round 1.06 ct) look more round.... but I also like the traditional setting which end up looking more square. I also like the fact that the n/s/e/w adds some solidity to the 2 prongs on the side as the cathedral is welded to them.... but I can''t decide on the look, and I wanted some opinions....

here are the photos:

Love B NS orientation of the prongs makes it even more unique!

 

[Hara]

I am starting to really lean towards the NS direction... i think we are gonna confirm sooooooon!!!!! it will be ready friday if we do!

 

[October2008bride]

I personally don''t love the NSEW orientation of the prongs - IMO if you want it to look rounder, go with a six prong.

Both are very lovely though, so if you like the NSEW, then go for it!! Don''t let my opinion sway you!!

 

[Lula]

I love the NSEW setting (B). I think it looks great from the side, it continues the band up through the prong -- very fluid!

 

[Hara]

I love 6 prongs... I just feel that it will be too much prong for a 1.06 ct center stone... i always felt that 6 prongs should be for bigger stones... so im trying to get a round feel with 4 prongs... not sure what to do just yet... i love both, trying to balance it out in my head with the help of votes... NSEW 3 - Traditional 2 so far

 

[mommy-of-4-kids]

I have a strong preference for option B. I think it looks better from the side.

 

[Hara]

4-2 NSEW.... can I have some more votes ppl?

 

[stonecutter2]

A.

I prefer the contrast of the diagonal orientation of the prongs to the band, rather than it lining up NSEW. Just a personal aesthetic thing. If you like it NSEW then do it!

 

[Hara]

You just got me thinking if the East-West prongs will cover the first 2 sidestones from the top down view... so I asked the jewler to send me that view... will keep you posted...

4-3 so far

 

[Ice Scream]

Date: 6/9/2009 3:17:48 PM
Author: stonecutter2
A.

I prefer the contrast of the diagonal orientation of the prongs to the band, rather than it lining up NSEW. Just a personal aesthetic thing. If you like it NSEW then do it!

I agree. I feel like with option B the two "EW" prongs will block some of the pave.

 

[AprilBaby]

I am kinda digging "B" , but how will it sit with a band?

 

[Hara]

I never thought of that before, thank you for pointing it out... I''m hoping that since the center prong setting is set higher up, on top of a barrel-like structure (with the 2 side accent diamonds on either side) it won''t interfere with the wedding band which will be normal size.... what do you think?

 

[VRBeauty]

I prefer A. The surprise stone with the prong growing out of it is a bit busy for my taste.

 

[Hara]

Here is the top down view.... the east west prongs do hide the side stones a little bit, hmmm..... but i don''t foresee myself or anyone staring at it at a frozen 90 degree angle like this ever... so i don''t know how serious it is....

it is a bit busy, you''re right VR Beauty.... i guess that''s why I need people''s opinions... i am VERY particular, and VERY indecisive, so it helps!!!

 

[Hara]

Sorry here is the top down view...

 

[Hara]

What about if I ask for a flat all around band...and remove the cathedral...? aye or nay??

 

[Ice Scream]

Date: 6/9/2009 5:12:22 PM
Author: Hara
What about if I ask for a flat all around band...and remove the cathedral...? aye or nay??

I would think this would hide the pave diamonds on the side even more if you were planning on going with the NSEW.

 

[ficklefaye]

i like B as well for this design, my ring is also a four prong but set the usual way and i''ve never thought it made my rb look square