McGinnis Shiny_Rock Premium Joined Jun 5, 2013 Messages 216 Feb 12, 2015 #1 Greetings, I'm currently looking at two diamonds both graded by GIA but one is 1.2 Carat J si2 1.5 HCA Crisp and clear with tiny carbon spot the other 1.14 Carat J si1 3.2 HCA Eye Clean but seems just a slightl bit cloudier in the pic. Difference is $50 in price. Which one would you pick?
Greetings, I'm currently looking at two diamonds both graded by GIA but one is 1.2 Carat J si2 1.5 HCA Crisp and clear with tiny carbon spot the other 1.14 Carat J si1 3.2 HCA Eye Clean but seems just a slightl bit cloudier in the pic. Difference is $50 in price. Which one would you pick?
Sponsored By: Shop Now Explore Thousands of Natural and Lab-Grown Diamonds Loose Diamonds for Sale Find a Ring for Any Style and Budget Shop Engagement Rings Dazzling Diamond Jewelry Goes with Everything Browse Diamond Jewelry
diamondseeker2006 Super_Ideal_Rock Premium Joined Jan 11, 2006 Messages 58,582 Feb 12, 2015 #2 I'd eliminate the stone with the 3+ HCA off the bat. Then I'd have to compare the first stone to other options with an excellent cut. Do you have magnified images of the first stone and idealscope images?
I'd eliminate the stone with the 3+ HCA off the bat. Then I'd have to compare the first stone to other options with an excellent cut. Do you have magnified images of the first stone and idealscope images?