Have you seen this ring? Help!

[gvillecreative]

Hello everyone!

I am now trying to decide between two settings that I fell in love with. One is a Beverly K and one is something else. I love them both and wanted some expert opinions:
http://www.topazery.com/antique-jewelry-item-rg2567.htm
http://www.topazery.com/antique-jewelry-item-rg2681.htm (which we can get through Perlmans, since Topazery is sold out)

Are there any pro / cons on the settings of these? I love the color of the stone on the 2nd ring, so I am wondering if anyone has ever seen the first setting on any other site, where I could get it with a different stone? Topazery has the same rg2567 ring with a cognac diamond, but I''m thinking more about champagne diamond coloring... or maybe a natural blue diamond. If I could figure out who makes it, or another place that sells the same setting, I could easily have it made...

Thoughts? Is one of these better than the other? Does anyone have any thoughts on the color of either stone?

 

[Tuckins1]

I don''t know about pro''s vs cons... But I prefer the look of the second ring better. I also like the brown stone better too. Beautiful!

 

[neatfreak]

Personally I''d go with the Beverly K because then you have the brand to stand behind the setting...

 

[facetedjewel]

I second Neat Freak''s vote and reasoning. Beverly K rings are exquisite. I especially love the north south, east west positioning of the prongs. It''s a standout. It gets my vote!

 

[MMT]

Hands down the second one. I love it!!!