shape
carat
color
clarity

happy and a little sad

16ocean

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
May 3, 2009
Messages
714
ok . . . I guess I just need a place to vent . . .
The happy: My younger brother(35) proposed to his GF(36)/ M and she accepted. She is a super sweet woman and I am happy they are getting married.
The sad: The diamond he chose, between me and the pricescope community . . . womp womp. Sigh. And she even has the tiniest fingers 4 1/2 or 4 1/4

I feel so petty for saying this but he -totally- could have done better. He is happy and I haven't said, nor will I say one word to diminish it. As a matter of fact when he sent me a photo via text of the ring I lied, and said he did a great job but between me, you and the discerning customer "meh".

Much earlier when he was first looking at stones I pointed him the direction of PS he got overwhelmed, "angles and details" left him feeling frustrated, too many options perhaps. He truly felt there was an easier way to get a ring. He works in LA not far from the diamond district and he had a lead from a friend at work who knows a good jeweler. yea. . .

So recently/ February we were talking he and shared he was going to propose to M. . .I -had- to say: "find out the shape of diamond she likes best". She wears a pear shaped pendent.
He had talked to M and she said she would like: "something unique" (oh my gosh that's hard) and also he talked to her mom who said, "I know she will love what ever you get her" also M has no pinterest page(I asked). I didn't want to pry too much like: Have the two of you just looked together?
but I got a feeling like he wanted this to be a project he did for her as husband so I backed off.

He decided on a cushion, not a round bz he felt that was too common(makes sense if she likes something unique) and the stone is very white that is what I can tell . . . sadly no/very little sparkle or fire.

Are cushions supposed to be sparkly?

When I looked at it close(not a loop just my eyes) there is a dark area in the middle, not an inclusion just a "dead area" perhaps, and my gosh it faces up on the smaller size, and this is w/ a tiny finger.

Anyway I just needed to vent.

I am quite sure he feels happy bz he got a "great deal". M is happy bz she met and will marry the love of her life. I am happy bz she is a great addition to the mix of family.

I do have to say a huge "thank you" to the pricescopers who have guided me, taught me and helped me to find and create lovely jewellery.
 
I get where you're coming from and we definitely understand! That old saying, you can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink is very true.

He picked a ring he thought was beautiful for his love and that's the main thing. That's the trouble, when you know what to look for you see the flaws, but your li'l Bruv bought what he thought was a ring beautiful enough for his beloved and I know you see that too. Cushions are weird ' animals' and I'm sure it has a beauty all of its own.

But I also understand your POV, all of us here do!
 
HI:

In an ideal world.....:))

They are both happy and that is best thing of all!

cheers--Sharon
 
It was the best diamond for the both of them. :saint:
 
The main thing is whether she is happy with the ring. If she loves it, that’s all that matters.
 
Cushions can be difficult, plus they face up small for their carat weight. But if your bro and his gf are happy that's all that counts!
 
Thank you -all- for your wise and kind words!
Totally agree w/ all sentiments: "they are happy" & "it's the best diamond for the two of them"

and

I get a new sister! :appl:
 
Yes, as long as they are both happy, that is what matters!

Although I’ve told both of my sons to come and ask for help if they are ever in the market for a diamond, I wonder if they will........:mrgreen2:
 
Aww yes glad they are both happy. That is all that matters. The material stuff is just that. Superficial and unimportant. Yes it would have been lovely if they had taken advantage of your expertise but they didnt and ignorance in this case can be bliss so I would leave it that was if he cannot get his money back. Wishing them a happy life. And don't let her find PS.8)

Yay to your new sister!:appl:
 
Aww yes glad they are both happy. That is all that matters. The material stuff is just that. Superficial and unimportant. Yes it would have been lovely if they had taken advantage of your expertise but they didnt and ignorance in this case can be bliss so I would leave it that was if he cannot get his money back. Wishing them a happy life. And don't let her find PS.8)

Yay to your new sister!:appl:
There are more important things than diamond?.:Up_to_something:.
slap4.gif
 
Aww yes glad they are both happy. That is all that matters. The material stuff is just that. Superficial and unimportant. Yes it would have been lovely if they had taken advantage of your expertise but they didnt and ignorance in this case can be bliss so I would leave it that was if he cannot get his money back. Wishing them a happy life. And don't let her find PS.8)

Yay to your new sister!:appl:

Amen to that!!
 
I've had somebody come back and say "why didn't you warn me!". I tried. Without outright saying you've wasted your money on junk, I asked if they had a good return policy (yes, supposedly), and told them to get it appraised. Well, when the then wife got it appraised for less than a third of what they paid, she hit the roof. Then I got crap. It was by then past the return period because they'd waited a couple of years. Not my problem! Better to stay out of it!
 
The scenario you described has happened to me a couple of times. You can't convince people. It is hard when you know they could have done better, got a better stone and saved money on top of it. But Missy is right, it is probably the least important thing in life.
 
Most people don't know they have ordinary diamonds anyway. I offered to help find my nephew something on a strict budget he instead wanted to select a stone "all by himself" despite my sister in law and I trying to talk him out of it and he indeed bought a complete piece of trash. But it's his stone he is happy with it, and so is she so enough said.
 
And don't let her find PS.8)



-giggle- giggle and grin!

Thanks all for being -here- so I could honestly vent. Appreciate it.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top