GOG''s stone - thoughts please

[anne]

http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/3195/

-For a (super) ideal stone, do you think that 35.06 Crown pavillon on this stone ist too steep?

-Is this a GOG''s classic?

Would you prefer this one from WF (although GOG''s is bigger, what i like)

http://www.whiteflash.com/hearts_arrows/A-Cut-Above-H-A-cut-diamond-329899.htm

Thank you for your help

anne

 

[strmrdr]

on the steep side but not a train wreck the long lgf% helps and the IS image looks great.
nope not a classic .. wrong angle combo too qualify.

Don''t like the shorter lgf% on the WF stone.

So there is something I don''t like about both.
Some will disagree but a slightly steep crown is less of an issue to me than a short lgf%.

 

[Ellen]

The CA is steeper than we typically see, however, the IS does indeed look great (and no worse than the WF stone).

Ask them to give it a good look over and give their thoughts on it. They'll be honest.

And let us know what you decide!