Engagement ring shape advice

[fletch173]

Confused:

My girlfriend indicated that we should like either a Round or Princess ring with the following caveat. A round ring in a solitaire setting or a princess ring with two sidestones (one on each side). I’m about to start searching for a ring and am not sure which direction to go as these are very different styles/shapes! Either way, I will be looking for a 1.25 ct, G, VS1/2, ring. It seems the round ring is the most popular sold from an engagement standpoint. Since I really don’t want to be pricing out and comparing two different shapes [one is confusing enough], any suggestions on where I should focus! In the end she said she would be fine with either and would trust my judgement!

While I’m not sure there is a right/wrong answer, I would appreciate any advice or suggestions.

 

[Kelli]

Rounds are more classic, face up bigger, and hide inclusions and color better than princess cuts. Plus, they tend to have the most sparkle of any of the cuts. I would personally go with that. Some women say they definitely want a princess cut, and that''s what they should have. But someone who is on the fence about what she prefers may be better off with the more timeless shape, as a round solitaire will never be out of style.

 

[Kelli]

One more thing, rounds are generally easier to shop for by numbers too. Good luck!

 

[Lorelei]

Welcome to Pricescope Fletch,

I agree with Kelli, unless she is really leaning towards a Princess, then a round might be the safest choice.

 

[vespergirl]

I would go with the round. My first engagement ring was an asscher (square shape) but I ended up trading it for a round with faces up bigger & sparkles more.

 

[CharmyPoo]

I am no expert but I completely agree with Kelli. I find that princess cuts have a very different look and unless someone really likes it and has a strong preference for it .... they may regret it in the future. Go with the round - timeless and gorgeous. Not sure if rounds cost more than princess cuts .. I know they are much more than cushions.

 

[fletch173]

Thanks to everyone for your input and advice! I now feel better! I will begin searching for a round ring this week! I''m sure I will reconsult pricescope as I line up a few options!

 

[Lorelei]

Just let us know if we can be of further assistance to you

 

[Indira-London]

Good advice from everyone who has posted so far.
Also, if ever she wanted the other 3 princess cut diamond ring - you could:
a) trade in your round brilliant - its the most popular and most expensive shape so is easier to trade
b) or if you are feeling really generous in future she can always have the 3 princess ring as a dress ring for a significant anniversary or major event (birth of first child)!