Emerald solitaire: which would you choose

[Buscope]

Hi! I am new here am am trying to choose a diamond for an anniversary ring (I currently only wear a wedding band, so this will be worn like an engagement ring). I have decided on an emerald solitaire, and have narrowed it down to three. Which would you choose (the 1.01 is the cheapest, the other two are about the same price, but all are within my budget). Thanks in advance for the help!

Option I: 1.01 ct
Cut: VG
Clarity: vvs1
Colour: G
Depth: 63.2
Table: 70
Girdle: med-slightly thick
Length/width ratio:1.45
Polish: vg
Symmetry: VG
Cutlet: no
Fluorescent: no
Measurement: 7.12 x 4.92 x 3.11

Option 2: 1.10 ct
Cut: VG
Clarity: vvs2
Colour: G
Depth: 63.3
Table: 63
Girdle: slightly thick-thick
Length/width ratio:1.44
Polish: vg
Symmetry: vg
Cutlet: no
Fluorescent: no
Measurement: 7.15 x 4.98 x 3.15

Option 3: 1.23 ct
Cut: VG
Clarity: vs1 (eye clean)
Colour: H
Depth: 67.9
Table: 61
Girdle: thick
Length/width ratio:1.46
Polish: excellent
Symmetry: vg
Cutlet: no
Fluorescent: strong
Measurement: 7.31 x 5.02 x 3.41

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Have you seen these in person? We'd need to see pictures of them. It is not possible to choose a diamond just from a lab report. Any one of them could be horrible or beautiful. If you do not have access to seeing them, then I'd suggest choosing a vendor who will provide pictures and ASET images for light return.

 

[heididdl]

I agree with DS not all EC are created equal ...You have to like the shape and the steps so pictures are a must

 

[Gypsy]

None. You can't buy an Emerald by the numbers. And the majority of emeralds are dogs.

You need pictures and an ASET if you are buying online.

Numbers on a lab report are largely meaningless with ECs or any fancy (not round brilliant).