Thanks to all the wonderful help I've gotten on this site I've narrowed my selection down to these 4 stones. If I go with a smaller one I'm going to add some bling to the mounting, and if I go with the bigger one I'm going to go with a solitaire. Please let me know your thoughts on the ASET's and whether you think the imperfections of the H&A images will make any difference to the naked eye? Thank you!
#1: 1 carat


GIA Facetware/Sarin (avgs):
Dia: 6.5
Depth%: 60.78
Table%: 57.1
Crown*: 33.05
Pav*: 43.47
HCA: 1.4, ex/ex/ex/vg
AGS PGS/Sarin (avgs):
D: 6.5
D%: 60.8
T%: 57
C*: 33.2
P*: 41.2
HCA: 2.1, vg/vg/vg/vg
AGS Report/Cert:
D: 6.5
D%: 60.9
T%: 57
C*: 33.1
P*: 41.1
HCA: 1.4, ex/ex/ex/vg
My thoughts: ASET looks good, but not sure if the imperfections of the H&A will have an impact on performance. HCA scares me a little... not knowing which set of measurements is correct swings from 1.4 to 2.1...
##################
#2 1.195 carat


Sarin Report (avgs):
D: 6.78
D%: 61.9
T%: 56.2
C*: 34.5
P*: 40.7
HCA: 1.0, ex/ex/ex/vg
AGS Cert: Identical to above
My thoughts: Looks pretty much perfect, but a bit more $/carat than the others. Not sure if green center is a problem. HCA looks great.
##################
#3 1.2 carat


GIA Facetware/Sarin (avgs):
D: 6.84
D%: 61.46
T%: 55
C*: 34.31
P*: 40.64
HCA: 0.7, ex/ex/ex/vg
AGS PGS/Sarin (avgs): Identical to above
GIA Report/Cert: Identical to above
My thoughts: Again, issues with H&A imperfections - do these affect eye performance? Does the green lighting in the center of the ASET affect eye performance? Do the imperfections of the two "arrow-stems" on the left side affect eye performance? HCA looks great.
##################
#4 1.3 carat


GIA Facetware/Sarin (avgs):
D: 7.03
D%: 61.16
T%: 57.9
C*: 34.21
P*: 40.98
HCA: 1.6, ex/vg/vg/vg
AGS PGS/Sarin (avgs): Identical to above
GIA Report/Cert: Identical to above
My thoughts: H&A look good, ASET shows an imperfection around 8 o'clock (green light at girdle). Not sure if this will affect eye performance. How is HCA under 2 but still predominantly "very good" ?? Will this affect eye performance?
All input greatly appreciated by myself and my lucky someone special!
#1: 1 carat


GIA Facetware/Sarin (avgs):
Dia: 6.5
Depth%: 60.78
Table%: 57.1
Crown*: 33.05
Pav*: 43.47
HCA: 1.4, ex/ex/ex/vg
AGS PGS/Sarin (avgs):
D: 6.5
D%: 60.8
T%: 57
C*: 33.2
P*: 41.2
HCA: 2.1, vg/vg/vg/vg
AGS Report/Cert:
D: 6.5
D%: 60.9
T%: 57
C*: 33.1
P*: 41.1
HCA: 1.4, ex/ex/ex/vg
My thoughts: ASET looks good, but not sure if the imperfections of the H&A will have an impact on performance. HCA scares me a little... not knowing which set of measurements is correct swings from 1.4 to 2.1...
##################
#2 1.195 carat


Sarin Report (avgs):
D: 6.78
D%: 61.9
T%: 56.2
C*: 34.5
P*: 40.7
HCA: 1.0, ex/ex/ex/vg
AGS Cert: Identical to above
My thoughts: Looks pretty much perfect, but a bit more $/carat than the others. Not sure if green center is a problem. HCA looks great.
##################
#3 1.2 carat


GIA Facetware/Sarin (avgs):
D: 6.84
D%: 61.46
T%: 55
C*: 34.31
P*: 40.64
HCA: 0.7, ex/ex/ex/vg
AGS PGS/Sarin (avgs): Identical to above
GIA Report/Cert: Identical to above
My thoughts: Again, issues with H&A imperfections - do these affect eye performance? Does the green lighting in the center of the ASET affect eye performance? Do the imperfections of the two "arrow-stems" on the left side affect eye performance? HCA looks great.
##################
#4 1.3 carat


GIA Facetware/Sarin (avgs):
D: 7.03
D%: 61.16
T%: 57.9
C*: 34.21
P*: 40.98
HCA: 1.6, ex/vg/vg/vg
AGS PGS/Sarin (avgs): Identical to above
GIA Report/Cert: Identical to above
My thoughts: H&A look good, ASET shows an imperfection around 8 o'clock (green light at girdle). Not sure if this will affect eye performance. How is HCA under 2 but still predominantly "very good" ?? Will this affect eye performance?
All input greatly appreciated by myself and my lucky someone special!