movie zombie
Super_Ideal_Rock
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2005
- Messages
- 11,879
probably in part because she got so much feedback initially saying to leave mom out of it - but that, at least for me, was based on hypotheticals, now shat she''s crossed some lines in reality forget it!Date: 1/11/2010 5:42:04 PM
Author: movie zombie
i''m surprised you haven''t let the mother know already.
mz
i agree with this....except that i don't think its Phoenix's responsibility to "deal with it". i'd probably give them the info she gave me as to where she is and how to contact her and let the parents go for it. i'd also be clear that the niece is no longer welcome in the home due to lack of respect for you, your home, and your rules.Date: 1/11/2010 7:25:26 PM
Author: ZoeBartlett
Phoenix, I've read this thread, but I haven't replied until now. If you haven't already, I'd contact your niece's parents and tell them everything, just as a heads up. Maybe ask them how they want to you to deal with it. Yes, your niece is an adult because of her age, but but she hasn't respected you or your husband. I'm 36, and I would never do the things she's done if I was visiting someone. As someone said, your house has become a hotel for her to come and go as she pleases. I would think that she'd want to spend more time with you -- her family. While I think it's fine for her to visit new-found friends, she's not acting like she appreciates that you've opened your house to her.
Date: 1/12/2010 12:47:54 AM
Author: Cehrabehra
just as a note, I keep seeing people say things like I''m 25 and I wouldn''t do this, I''m 30 and I wouldn''t do this, I''m 35 and I wouldn''t do this... and that doesn''t surprise me. Those ages are far more mature than 19. If anything 19 is the MOST immature age - you have the ''rights'' of an adult and the wisdom of a child. I don''t think she should be held to those standards, but I think she should be held accountable for reality - whatever consequences that may bear - and right now her auntie is disappointed and concerned and she should say so. An adult would expect nothing else, she should have that dose of reality. But don''t be surprised she''s in this phase... in many ways its normal, but thankfully (hopefully) temporary.
Date: 1/12/2010 1:41:50 AM
Author: Phoenix
Thanks very much again, everyone, for replying and for advice/ input.
Well, I have forwarded my niece''s email to my SIL (who has responded) as well as Skyped my brother. They both seem to believe that her daughter is a good girl and that she can do no wrong!My SIL seems rather indignant, a tad defensive if I might add. SIL insists that if her daughter was a party-animal, she wouldn''t have got good grades from school!! She seems to have missed the points entirely that i) my niece has behaved in not a very polite or considerate manner towards us; and ii) she may be putting herself and us in danger by hanging out with people that we don''t know anything about; and more to the point, is she really hanging out with this girl or is she hanging out with strangers - for eg. the boy she''d just met a few days ago and is using her friend as an excuse/ pretense to us and to her parents. God knows, she admits she''s used people before and you know what, judging from her behaviour, I wouldn''t be surprised that she uses people, including DH and I.
The most important thing is that she is here now, under our care; we''re supposed to be responsible for her (whatever she gets up to back home is her and her parents'' biz).
Anyway, we''ve done our part now and if anything happens to my niece, that won''t be our responsibility! Her parents have been warned!
your comment reminded me of something I did when I was 13 - 13 and a couple months (summer before 8th grade). I went to australia with a ballet company for just under a month (no parents) and we went to brisbane and were told we could spent 3 or 4 hours walking around but not to go farther than a small block radius - but me and the other 2 girls I was with (both younger than me) decided we''d catch a bus to the exhibition on the edge of town (25 miles or kilometers - don''t recall which) where we went on all of these rides and won stuffed animals and rode the bus back. It did not seem at all a big deal at the time. If this girl was sheltered at all (and even though it''s CA berkley can be a somewhat sheltered place, albeit pot exposed) she may not even realize she could possibly put herself in danger.Date: 1/12/2010 1:32:21 AM
Author: thing2of2
Date: 1/12/2010 12:47:54 AM
Author: Cehrabehra
just as a note, I keep seeing people say things like I''m 25 and I wouldn''t do this, I''m 30 and I wouldn''t do this, I''m 35 and I wouldn''t do this... and that doesn''t surprise me. Those ages are far more mature than 19. If anything 19 is the MOST immature age - you have the ''rights'' of an adult and the wisdom of a child. I don''t think she should be held to those standards, but I think she should be held accountable for reality - whatever consequences that may bear - and right now her auntie is disappointed and concerned and she should say so. An adult would expect nothing else, she should have that dose of reality. But don''t be surprised she''s in this phase... in many ways its normal, but thankfully (hopefully) temporary.
Very true. I know 19 isn''t quite adult, but I do think 19 is old enough to have a good head on your shoulders. Obviously I don''t know her niece at all, but when I was 17 I was able to make good decisions at home and while traveling. I wasn''t perfect, but I certainly didn''t put myself in a situation where I would be kidnapped and sold into sex slavery like some people have mentioned!
So who''s to say her niece isn''t making smart decisions? Honestly, I don''t really think hanging out with a guy she just met qualifies as a bad decision...if that was the case none of us would be married!
I think you are missing an important piece of the puzzle here....all the times you went, you were with people (family) that you trusted. This girl is alone and meeting up/spending the night with strangers that she just met. That is the part I can''t get past b/c of safety issues.Date: 1/12/2010 12:01:31 AM
Author: thing2of2
I''m late to this thread but I''ve read it and I have to offer a a view from the other side. When I was in college my brother (who is 5 years older than me) was stationed in Germany and he invited me and my twin sister to come stay with him over our spring break and offered to pay for part of our airfare. We excitedly accepted, not realizing that in his mind this meant that we would sit at his apartment or just stay in the little town he was stationed in and then go visit cathedrals and museums with him and his wife when he was off. (Call me uncultured but they all look the same after a while-stone and stained glass!)
It was the least fun trip I''ve ever been on because he tried to dictate everything we did based on his own interests. This culminated in a big fight when we traveled to Munich with him and his wife and he got angry that I wanted to stop by a store I had been to the night before to pick up a jacket I liked before we left town. Yes-we had a fight over a stop at a store. It was RIDICULOUS. He was apparently angry that we didn''t enjoy visiting every cathedral in Germany. My sister and I were 21 at the time and had both been to Europe twice before by ourselves so we didn''t need the chaperoning or the trip planning. We just wanted to hang out, eat good food, drink good beer and visit a museum or two.
And I think 19 is plenty old enough to make good decisions. The first time I went to Europe I was 17 and my sister and I backpacked around for 2 months with a friend of ours who had lived with us as an exchange student our junior year of high school. As 17-year-olds, we were perfectly capable of making good decisions and were safe for the entire trip. I have no doubt that an intelligent 19-year-old will be able to do the same. I understand there are cultural issues at play here that didn''t apply in my situation, but I think it''s also important to take into account the fact that your niece lives in the U.S. and may be more ''American'' in her thinking.
I understand that she''s visiting you and staying with you, but what do you expect from her? Do you think she should be at your house all day and night because she''s staying with you? (I''m genuinely curious and am not trying to sound mean here.)
Date: 1/12/2010 11:38:34 AM
Author: steph72276
Date: 1/12/2010 12:01:31 AM
Author: thing2of2
I''m late to this thread but I''ve read it and I have to offer a a view from the other side. When I was in college my brother (who is 5 years older than me) was stationed in Germany and he invited me and my twin sister to come stay with him over our spring break and offered to pay for part of our airfare. We excitedly accepted, not realizing that in his mind this meant that we would sit at his apartment or just stay in the little town he was stationed in and then go visit cathedrals and museums with him and his wife when he was off. (Call me uncultured but they all look the same after a while-stone and stained glass!)
It was the least fun trip I''ve ever been on because he tried to dictate everything we did based on his own interests. This culminated in a big fight when we traveled to Munich with him and his wife and he got angry that I wanted to stop by a store I had been to the night before to pick up a jacket I liked before we left town. Yes-we had a fight over a stop at a store. It was RIDICULOUS. He was apparently angry that we didn''t enjoy visiting every cathedral in Germany. My sister and I were 21 at the time and had both been to Europe twice before by ourselves so we didn''t need the chaperoning or the trip planning. We just wanted to hang out, eat good food, drink good beer and visit a museum or two.
And I think 19 is plenty old enough to make good decisions. The first time I went to Europe I was 17 and my sister and I backpacked around for 2 months with a friend of ours who had lived with us as an exchange student our junior year of high school. As 17-year-olds, we were perfectly capable of making good decisions and were safe for the entire trip. I have no doubt that an intelligent 19-year-old will be able to do the same. I understand there are cultural issues at play here that didn''t apply in my situation, but I think it''s also important to take into account the fact that your niece lives in the U.S. and may be more ''American'' in her thinking.
I understand that she''s visiting you and staying with you, but what do you expect from her? Do you think she should be at your house all day and night because she''s staying with you? (I''m genuinely curious and am not trying to sound mean here.)
I think you are missing an important piece of the puzzle here....all the times you went, you were with people (family) that you trusted. This girl is alone and meeting up/spending the night with strangers that she just met. That is the part I can''t get past b/c of safety issues.
Thank you, DiaDiva.Date: 1/12/2010 1:44:31 AM
Author: DiaDiva
Date: 1/12/2010 1:41:50 AM
Author: Phoenix
Thanks very much again, everyone, for replying and for advice/ input.
Well, I have forwarded my niece''s email to my SIL (who has responded) as well as Skyped my brother. They both seem to believe that her daughter is a good girl and that she can do no wrong!My SIL seems rather indignant, a tad defensive if I might add. SIL insists that if her daughter was a party-animal, she wouldn''t have got good grades from school!! She seems to have missed the points entirely that i) my niece has behaved in not a very polite or considerate manner towards us; and ii) she may be putting herself and us in danger by hanging out with people that we don''t know anything about; and more to the point, is she really hanging out with this girl or is she hanging out with strangers - for eg. the boy she''d just met a few days ago and is using her friend as an excuse/ pretense to us and to her parents. God knows, she admits she''s used people before and you know what, judging from her behaviour, I wouldn''t be surprised that she uses people, including DH and I.
The most important thing is that she is here now, under our care; we''re supposed to be responsible for her (whatever she gets up to back home is her and her parents'' biz).
Anyway, we''ve done our part now and if anything happens to my niece, that won''t be our responsibility! Her parents have been warned!
Phoenix, so sorry to hear this about your niece. I''m glad you told her parents and they''ve been forewarned.
Are you still in Singapore? Do you still want to hook up?
I think you handled the situation perfectly. I''m sorry your niece''s visit didn''t go as well as you had planned.Date: 1/13/2010 7:09:25 AM
Author: Phoenix
Thank you very much, everyone, for writing and giving me your input/ suggestions. You guys are really THE BEST!
Well, I sat my niece down yesterday and had a heart-to-heart talk to her. I basically told her she''d been disrespectful and told her that she should have asked us - in person - if we''d mind if she stayed elsewhere and that the way she''d conducted herself was not acceptable. I told her that although she''s over the legal age (well, mostly except the drinking bit) in the US, if she insists on behaving like a teenager than that''s the way I will treat her. I told her that we''ve had a couple of nieces visiting before (one from my side of the family and the other from DH''s) and even though they were not that much older than she is, we never had to worry about them. She apologized (though I don''t know if this was sincere).
What I didn''t do though was talk about the lies she''d fed us (I haven''t told you guys in detail about these lies) nor the safety aspect of her supposedly staying at her friend''s house. With regard to the former, I figure that I''m not her mother and also she has to learn honesty and integrity all by herself, I can''t really teach her that. As to the latter, her parents are insistent that she is safe, so who am I to say otherwise?!!
Anyway, she''s left our place now and I pray to God that she''s going to be ok for the remainder of her holiday here. I''ll breathe a sign of relief when she''s back home.
Good Lord!! I think half of my hair turned grey these past few days!!
Date: 1/13/2010 8:32:22 AM
Author: Phoenix
Date: 1/12/2010 1:44:31 AM
Author: DiaDiva
Date: 1/12/2010 1:41:50 AM
Author: Phoenix
Thanks very much again, everyone, for replying and for advice/ input.
Well, I have forwarded my niece's email to my SIL (who has responded) as well as Skyped my brother. They both seem to believe that her daughter is a good girl and that she can do no wrong!My SIL seems rather indignant, a tad defensive if I might add. SIL insists that if her daughter was a party-animal, she wouldn't have got good grades from school!! She seems to have missed the points entirely that i) my niece has behaved in not a very polite or considerate manner towards us; and ii) she may be putting herself and us in danger by hanging out with people that we don't know anything about; and more to the point, is she really hanging out with this girl or is she hanging out with strangers - for eg. the boy she'd just met a few days ago and is using her friend as an excuse/ pretense to us and to her parents. God knows, she admits she's used people before and you know what, judging from her behaviour, I wouldn't be surprised that she uses people, including DH and I.
The most important thing is that she is here now, under our care; we're supposed to be responsible for her (whatever she gets up to back home is her and her parents' biz).
Anyway, we've done our part now and if anything happens to my niece, that won't be our responsibility! Her parents have been warned!
Phoenix, so sorry to hear this about your niece. I'm glad you told her parents and they've been forewarned.
Are you still in Singapore? Do you still want to hook up?
Thank you, DiaDiva.
We didn't go to Singapore. I'm still planning to go there either later this month or next month. I'd LOVE to hook up. Shall I let you know later closer to the time?