Diamond choice , which one is the best?

[JD2012]

Can you please let me know what is the "best" diamond i should choose for my g/f?

All are GIA Certified and are 1 or 1.01 brilliant cut diamond. I really appreciate. My budget is not big so none of them will be perfect. There are 5 options to choose from.

Cut Clarity Color Polish Symm Flour Table Depth Measurements Crown Pavillion
Very Good SI1 F Excellent Excellent None 56% 63.3% 6.31-6.36 x 4.01 36.6 40.8
Excellent SI1 F Excellent Excellent Med Blue 60% 60.0% 6.53-6.56 x 3.93 33.5 41.2
Excellent SI1 G Very Good Excellent Med Blue 59% 60.9% 6.47-6.51 x 3.95 33.0 41.4
Very Good SI1 F Very Good Excellent None 56% 61.6% 6.38-6.42 x 3.94 34.0 40.6
Good SI1 F Excellent Good None 57% 63.3% 6.37-6.45 x 4.06 38.0 41.0


Thanking you for you time

JD2012

 

[TitanCi]

Well, based off the very LIMITED info you give... None. Maybe stone 4 if those are the ONLY choices you have, even if the cut is very good...unfortunately, what you post is not enough info. Do you have certification numbers?

 

[JD2012]

Tx so much for the reply


Please find GIA Cert No's for 5 options:

GIA Cut Clarity Color Polish Symm Flour Table Depth Measurements Crown Pavillion
1139492614 Very Good SI1 F Excellent Excellent None 56% 63.3% 6.31-6.36 x 4.01 36.6 40.8
1129790895 Excellent SI1 F Excellent Excellent Med Blue 60% 60.0% 6.53-6.56 x 3.93 33.5 41.2
2136530119 Excellent SI1 G Very Good Excellent Med Blue 59% 60.9% 6.47-6.51 x 3.95 33.0 41.4
2131504357 Very Good SI1 F Very Good Excellent None 56% 61.6% 6.38-6.42 x 3.94 34.0 40.6
5136143126 Good SI1 F Excellent Good None 57% 63.3% 6.37-6.45 x 4.06 38.0 41.0


I was given previous advice on Pricescope forum about what I should look for in terms of table/depth/pavillion/crown etc. No. 4 meets most of these except pavillion. You might explain what is "wrong" with No 3 and 4 (which seem the best to me) but I really have very little idea or knowledge on this area.

Your advice is much appreciated.

JD2012

 

[stone-cold11]

https://myapps.gia.edu/ReportCheckPortal/getReportData.do?&reportno=1139492614&weight=1.00

https://myapps.gia.edu/ReportCheckPortal/getReportData.do?&reportno=1129790895&weight=1.02

https://myapps.gia.edu/ReportCheckPortal/getReportData.do?&reportno=2136530119&weight=1.01

https://myapps.gia.edu/ReportCheckPortal/getReportData.do?&reportno=2131504357&weight=1.00

https://myapps.gia.edu/ReportCheckPortal/getReportData.do?&reportno=5136143126&weight=1.03

#2 & #3 could work, safer bet would be 2 but need idealscope image to confirm no leakage. #4 is good except for the thick girdle hiding some weight to get over the 1 carat mark where there is a sharp jump in $/carat, could probably be a 0.98c stone with the same dimension but a medium girdle. #1 and #5 probably junk compare to the other 3.

 

[JD2012]

Tx a mill for ur help. Will request idealscope for no. 2 and will put on forum when received,