Debating between two stones?

[wetseel22]

So looking at two stones right now for an engagement ring:
1. 2.03 carat, Color G, VS2, CUT= GIA Ex, Polish =VG, Sym = EX, Floresc = NONE, D= 61.1%, T = 56%, Crown = 35 deg, Pav = 40.6 deg
2. 2.08 carat, Color G, VS2, CUT= GIA VG, Polish =EX, Sym = EX, Floresc = NONE, D=60%, T= 60%, Crown = 36 deg, Pav = 40.2 deg

Price was about the same. ~20-21k. Which one would you go with?

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 6/11/2009 2:03:02 PM
Author:wetseel22
So looking at two stones right now for an engagement ring:
1. 2.03 carat, Color G, VS2, CUT= GIA Ex, Polish =VG, Sym = EX, Floresc = NONE, D= 61.1%, T = 56%, Crown = 35 deg, Pav = 40.6 deg
2. 2.08 carat, Color G, VS2, CUT= GIA VG, Polish =EX, Sym = EX, Floresc = NONE, D=60%, T= 60%, Crown = 36 deg, Pav = 40.2 deg

Price was about the same. ~20-21k. Which one would you go with?

Easy choice, first one for me. Are these with an online vendor or store jeweller?

I will also get this thread moved to Rocky Talk for you.

 

[wetseel22]

Interesting. What was your logic in choosing #1?

This was through a store.

Thanks!

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 6/11/2009 2:08:46 PM
Author: wetseel22
Interesting. What was your logic in choosing #1?

This was through a store.

Thanks!

The proportions are better than the second one, it is a '' safer'' choice.

 

[Todd Gray]

This topic and the same two diamonds are being discussed in two threads within the Rocky Talk forum, let''s drop this thread since it has been discussed in more detail here

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 6/11/2009 3:30:46 PM
Author: Todd Gray
This topic and the same two diamonds are being discussed in two threads within the Rocky Talk forum, let's drop this thread since it has been discussed in more detail here

Yes Todd, I have seen the other thread, I just wanted to answer this question.