Haven
Super_Ideal_Rock
- Joined
- Feb 15, 2007
- Messages
- 13,166
Ugh! The only two things I specifically said NO to were strapless dresses, (not on this body, at my age, uh-uh), and hotel ballrooms with those ugly floral patterned carpets in dayglo colors! Yeeshh!!Date: 11/27/2007 11:32:33 AM
Author: NewEnglandLady
I completely agreee with misysu and neatfreak. I think ''cookie cutter'' is synonomous with ''generic''. In addition to what misysu wrote, I''d add that cookie cutter weddings usually take place in a hotel ballroom or golf club with the generic flowers, dress, dancing, matching BM dresses, etc. that neatfreak listed.
Date: 11/27/2007 12:02:56 PM
Author: Haven
Oh, dear--I didn''t even think about how this might be a touchy subject. I''m really just curious about this because I''d never heard of a ''cookie-cutter wedding'' before PS, and since I''m planning a wedding I thought it would be nice to know.
Thank you for all of your responses. Now I have another question--what are some of the best personal touches you''ve seen at weddings? (Or what are you planning for your own?)
Thanks again!
OH, no no no no no--don't misunderstand, I'm not looking for help figuring out what to do for MY wedding, I have all that covered. I'm really just interested in hearing about what you've seen at other weddings because, well, I'm interested! I think the whole mix of tradition and personal flair is just plain interesting, and I love to hear about it.Date: 11/27/2007 12:26:36 PM
Author: neatfreak
Date: 11/27/2007 12:02:56 PM
Author: Haven
Oh, dear--I didn't even think about how this might be a touchy subject. I'm really just curious about this because I'd never heard of a 'cookie-cutter wedding' before PS, and since I'm planning a wedding I thought it would be nice to know.
Thank you for all of your responses. Now I have another question--what are some of the best personal touches you've seen at weddings? (Or what are you planning for your own?)
Thanks again!
Haven, I think the key to all this is that WE can't tell you what the best personal touches were because those touches were personal for OTHER people. Just follow your heart and pick things that YOU truly love, and don't just do things because you are 'supposed to'.
Think of your own ideas that aren't in bridal magazines, add things that really MEAN something to you and your FI, and don't do readings, dances, traditions, ONLY because you have to. Just pick the things that are really important to YOU and incorporate them.
Date: 11/27/2007 12:02:56 PM
Author: Haven
Thank you for all of your responses. Now I have another question--what are some of the best personal touches you've seen at weddings? (Or what are you planning for your own?)
Date: 11/27/2007 12:38:42 PM
Author: Haven
Date: 11/27/2007 12:26:36 PM
Author: neatfreak
Date: 11/27/2007 12:02:56 PM
Author: Haven
Oh, dear--I didn't even think about how this might be a touchy subject. I'm really just curious about this because I'd never heard of a 'cookie-cutter wedding' before PS, and since I'm planning a wedding I thought it would be nice to know.
Thank you for all of your responses. Now I have another question--what are some of the best personal touches you've seen at weddings? (Or what are you planning for your own?)
Thanks again!
Haven, I think the key to all this is that WE can't tell you what the best personal touches were because those touches were personal for OTHER people. Just follow your heart and pick things that YOU truly love, and don't just do things because you are 'supposed to'.
Think of your own ideas that aren't in bridal magazines, add things that really MEAN something to you and your FI, and don't do readings, dances, traditions, ONLY because you have to. Just pick the things that are really important to YOU and incorporate them.
OH, no no no no no--don't misunderstand, I'm not looking for help figuring out what to do for MY wedding, I have all that covered. I'm really just interested in hearing about what you've seen at other weddings because, well, I'm interested! I think the whole mix of tradition and personal flair is just plain interesting, and I love to hear about it.
And when I originally posted this thread it was because I just couldn't fathom what a cookie cutter wedding would look like, because I've never been to a wedding that DIDN'T reflect the couple. That's all. I've honestly never heard anyone call another person's wedding 'cookie cutter' outside of PS, so I was intrigued.
ETA: I suppose I should play my own game. My favorite personal touch was at my best friend's wedding. She had recently fallen in love with a particular song on the radio, so once she was engaged she figured she'd contact the artist and see if there was any way he could play the song during their ceremony. Of course I thought this was crazy--contact a rising star of a musician and ask him to play your wedding? Well, it just so happened that this artist is from Chicago and he was going to be in town the weekend of her wedding so he agreed! He came to the wedding with two of his band members, and they played the song and he sang the lyrics during the processional. It was really very touching, especially for everyone who knew how much she loved that song.
Very well put. I am not a BIW but this thread kind of stressed me out. I plan on choosing what I want in my wedding because I want it, not because it is trendy, and not because it is NOT trendy. When it is my turn that isDate: 11/27/2007 1:44:51 PM
Author: basil
There's a fine line between being cookie-cutter and being traditional. And there's a fine line between doing something personal and doing something different just to be different.
Do what you like and who cares. Most people probably won't notice the details all that much. The majority of your guests won't surf the knot and won't realize that everyone else is going a candy buffet too or that a bunch of other people wore Maggie Sottero. But if you're more Sex Pistols than Canon in D, then go for it! But just cause everyone uses Canon in D doesn't mean it's an unoriginal, cookie-cutter choice - things are popular for a reason.
And maybe the Sex Pistols don't make good wedding music for a reason, too![]()
Date: 11/27/2007 1:44:51 PM
Author: basil
There''s a fine line between being cookie-cutter and being traditional. And there''s a fine line between doing something personal and doing something different just to be different.
Do what you like and who cares. Most people probably won''t notice the details all that much. The majority of your guests won''t surf the knot and won''t realize that everyone else is going a candy buffet too or that a bunch of other people wore Maggie Sottero. But if you''re more Sex Pistols than Canon in D, then go for it! But just cause everyone uses Canon in D doesn''t mean it''s an unoriginal, cookie-cutter choice - things are popular for a reason.
And maybe the Sex Pistols don''t make good wedding music for a reason, too![]()
Yeah, what she said!Date: 11/27/2007 2:30:49 PM
Author: sumbride
I think a cookie-cutter wedding happens when people don''t really think about what THEY want and are trying too hard to ''do it right''. If the mom does most of the planning, or a wedding planner for that matter, there''s a chance that it won''t reflect the couple and then you have a generic boring cookie-cutter wedding.
I honestly don''t know that I''ve been to a rote cookie-cutter wedding... sure, I''ve seen elements that drove me crazy, like my friend''s reception that I swear was ''wedding cd vol. 1'' including the chicken dance, YMCA, celebration, hokey pokey and we are family, ALL IN A ROW. It was a bit much. But at that same wedding, we were delighted to note that the bride and groom served ice cream with their cake because the BRIDE LOVES ICE CREAM. It was awesome and special. It also kind of helped me overlook their entrance song being Def Leppard''s ''Pour some sugar on me'' which was, um, slightly inappropriate.
When we planned our wedding, we decided to make it very ''us''. Even though it was a fancy country club shindig for hundreds, we had it outside instead of in a church. We used secular music WITH LYRICS for all our processional/recessionals. We had non-matching bridesmaid dresses and multiple flower girls. We served punch to all the guests before they were seated for the wedding. We exited the ceremony in a golf cart. Our first dance was to an REM song because that''s why we met. We didn''t do a garter or bouquet toss because it wasn''t ''us''. We stayed until the end! And we had a blast. THAT is what makes a wedding personal. It''s not about color schemes or gimmicks, it''s about genuine honest FEELING and people can tell if it reflects the couple. And they like it when it does.
As long as you put thought into WHY you''re doing something it won''t be cookie cutter.
Date: 11/27/2007 5:18:45 PM
Author: Independent Gal
Here's something that might help.
When I first started planning and was feeling bummed / confused, someone on here suggested to me that I stop, and make a list of the 5 things that were most meaningful and important to me for my wedding day, and plan around that.