comparing two stones princess cut

[brandon3_16]

guys need to know if this should look like a ideal cut, not sure as I am new to this


Cut Princess
Certification GIA before cut was measured
GIA report number 16862294
6.35X6.23 4.52

weight 1.52
color grade H
clarity VS2

depth 72.6%
table 71%
Girdle Medium to very thick
culet None

Cost $11000

Any help would be nice, comparing to a Peerless

1.5 carat; H; 6.28X6.23; VS2; AGS000; cost $14000

Polish Excellent
symmetry Excellent
fluorescence None

 

[dockman3]

Brandon-

I don''t know that much about princess cuts, but I do know that they are best evaluated in person or with pictures. Nothing in those numbers sticks out to me as being out of bounds for a good stone, but if you can see these two in person side by side, that is your best bet. If you can''t tell a difference between them, then I say go for the cheaper one. But really, we need some pictures or ASET images or something else to go off of. Hope this helps!

 

[jstarfireb]

Ditto, with the addition that I wouldn't go any higher than "thick" on a girdle because it's wasted carat weight. How about this 1.5 ct ideal princess? It's a lot less expensive than the Peerless and promises to be one of the most beautiful princess cuts out there.

ETA: This princess also looks very nice; it's bigger than the stones you're looking at, and for less! There's a chip in one of the corners, though; it could probably be protected and hidden from view by a V-shaped prong. Ask WF about that if you're interested in the stone.