Comparing ASETs

[huskeypm]

Hi
I''m having trouble making heads or tails of ASET images for princess cuts. Qualitative pointers I''ve read included looking for blue in the image as well as avoiding white regions, which are indicative of leakage. However, is there an appreciable difference in light performance between these two images? (sorry for the links, was having difficulties uploading the images)
http://pkh.caltech.edu/public_files/ASET_2.jpg
http://pkh.caltech.edu/public_files/ASET.jpg

The latter image has white regions along the edges, while the former has diffuse white regions along the edges.

Thanks for your help!

 

[Lorelei]

This chart should help - http://www.ideal-scope.com/using_reference_chart_ASET.asp

 

[Ellen]

Date: 10/10/2008 12:00:30 AM
Author:huskeypm
Hi
I''m having trouble making heads or tails of ASET images for princess cuts. Qualitative pointers I''ve read included looking for blue in the image as well as avoiding white regions, which are indicative of leakage. However, is there an appreciable difference in light performance between these two images? (sorry for the links, was having difficulties uploading the images)
http://pkh.caltech.edu/public_files/ASET_2.jpg
http://pkh.caltech.edu/public_files/ASET.jpg

The latter image has white regions along the edges, while the former has diffuse white regions along the edges.

Thanks for your help!

That question would be best for Jon at GOG. We can only guess by the ASET, though to me, the first one looks like it could be the better since there is more red, which you want. But just give them a call and ask which one is better! They will be quite honest.

 

[stone-cold11]

Ditto above. my preference will be 1, looks like less leakage.