dragonfly411
Ideal_Rock
- Joined
- Jun 25, 2007
- Messages
- 7,378
ksinger|1306323972|2929798 said:And the worst part is, these deaths were almost entirely preventable. We here in Oklahoma have been marveling at how so many people died in Joplin. Somebody - especially in other plains states where there really should be no excuse - needs to take a good long look at the warning systems in place. We were horrified to lose 41 in the May 3rd tornados - there were 60 in the state that day, one of which was a long-track F5 that ploughed through several highly populated sections of the OKC metro. We had HOURS of advance warning.
And Joplin loses in the hundreds? Something is not right here. I read that the residents only had 20 minutes warning. That is utterly criminal in this day and age. Of course, it could be too that the psychology of the residents themselves doesn't take this stuff seriously. In Oklahoma we really are cats on hot tin roofs about storms. People need more warning, but they also MUST HEED THEM when they come.
Last I checked, we had 4? tornadoes last night - two of them long-track wedge tornados of F4 or higher, and the current death toll is 6. The point is, it isn't in the hundreds.
Logan Sapphire|1306334476|2929866 said:ksinger|1306323972|2929798 said:And the worst part is, these deaths were almost entirely preventable. We here in Oklahoma have been marveling at how so many people died in Joplin. Somebody - especially in other plains states where there really should be no excuse - needs to take a good long look at the warning systems in place. We were horrified to lose 41 in the May 3rd tornados - there were 60 in the state that day, one of which was a long-track F5 that ploughed through several highly populated sections of the OKC metro. We had HOURS of advance warning.
And Joplin loses in the hundreds? Something is not right here. I read that the residents only had 20 minutes warning. That is utterly criminal in this day and age. Of course, it could be too that the psychology of the residents themselves doesn't take this stuff seriously. In Oklahoma we really are cats on hot tin roofs about storms. People need more warning, but they also MUST HEED THEM when they come.
Last I checked, we had 4? tornadoes last night - two of them long-track wedge tornados of F4 or higher, and the current death toll is 6. The point is, it isn't in the hundreds.
I asked DH about what you said and here is his response:
"The problem is people get used to the sirens and don't do anything when they sound. The weather service has said 20 mins was excellent time and is much better than years ago when they would have had maybe 10 mins notice. The other problem is the tornado went through some of the older sections of town. The houses were probably very flimsy and didn't have basements."
DH's mom's house does not have a basement either but only a crawl space, so she rode out the storm in a neighbor's basement.
NewEnglandLady|1306348269|2930032 said:My mom just called me (Kansas City area) and she's been under her desk since 10:30 this morning. She and all of her coworkers have been sharing food in their desks because they can't leave for lunch (or really even their cubes). I guess it's an active tornado day in the area, though it seems not many are staying on the ground for long.
merilenda|1306337373|2929907 said:Logan Sapphire|1306334476|2929866 said:ksinger|1306323972|2929798 said:And the worst part is, these deaths were almost entirely preventable. We here in Oklahoma have been marveling at how so many people died in Joplin. Somebody - especially in other plains states where there really should be no excuse - needs to take a good long look at the warning systems in place. We were horrified to lose 41 in the May 3rd tornados - there were 60 in the state that day, one of which was a long-track F5 that ploughed through several highly populated sections of the OKC metro. We had HOURS of advance warning.
And Joplin loses in the hundreds? Something is not right here. I read that the residents only had 20 minutes warning. That is utterly criminal in this day and age. Of course, it could be too that the psychology of the residents themselves doesn't take this stuff seriously. In Oklahoma we really are cats on hot tin roofs about storms. People need more warning, but they also MUST HEED THEM when they come.
Last I checked, we had 4? tornadoes last night - two of them long-track wedge tornados of F4 or higher, and the current death toll is 6. The point is, it isn't in the hundreds.
I asked DH about what you said and here is his response:
"The problem is people get used to the sirens and don't do anything when they sound. The weather service has said 20 mins was excellent time and is much better than years ago when they would have had maybe 10 mins notice. The other problem is the tornado went through some of the older sections of town. The houses were probably very flimsy and didn't have basements."
DH's mom's house does not have a basement either but only a crawl space, so she rode out the storm in a neighbor's basement.
I agree with LS's DH. I'm from Missouri, and growing up here, you hear the sirens going off so often that it's really easy to ignore them. They also test them so often that I've almost learned to tune them out completely. Now if the weather looks bad and I hear the sirens, I will check to see what the warning says. But I don't immediately assume that I need to get to the basement. I know it's better to be safe than sorry, but it's still hard to really blame people.
I would guess that a large part of the death toll & destruction is in the nature of the storm and its location as well. Some tornadoes/storm systems just allow for more advanced warning than others. Some develop so quickly, that advanced warning is not possible. I know that Joplin has been under tornado warning a number of times since this happened, and we've had strong storms all over the state all week. But none of those caused the level of destruction because the details were different. This particular tornado tore a path through a populated area, destroying the hospital, high school, churches, etc. And it sounds like it came on more quickly than anyone had thought. I read that the hospital heard the warning that they were expecting to be hit in 20 minutes, and the windows were being blown out 5 minutes later. I guess I just don't think anyone is to blame, and that this tragedy occurred mostly due to circumstance.
ksinger|1306363029|2930236 said:merilenda|1306337373|2929907 said:Logan Sapphire|1306334476|2929866 said:ksinger|1306323972|2929798 said:And the worst part is, these deaths were almost entirely preventable. We here in Oklahoma have been marveling at how so many people died in Joplin. Somebody - especially in other plains states where there really should be no excuse - needs to take a good long look at the warning systems in place. We were horrified to lose 41 in the May 3rd tornados - there were 60 in the state that day, one of which was a long-track F5 that ploughed through several highly populated sections of the OKC metro. We had HOURS of advance warning.
And Joplin loses in the hundreds? Something is not right here. I read that the residents only had 20 minutes warning. That is utterly criminal in this day and age. Of course, it could be too that the psychology of the residents themselves doesn't take this stuff seriously. In Oklahoma we really are cats on hot tin roofs about storms. People need more warning, but they also MUST HEED THEM when they come.
Last I checked, we had 4? tornadoes last night - two of them long-track wedge tornados of F4 or higher, and the current death toll is 6. The point is, it isn't in the hundreds.
I asked DH about what you said and here is his response:
"The problem is people get used to the sirens and don't do anything when they sound. The weather service has said 20 mins was excellent time and is much better than years ago when they would have had maybe 10 mins notice. The other problem is the tornado went through some of the older sections of town. The houses were probably very flimsy and didn't have basements."
DH's mom's house does not have a basement either but only a crawl space, so she rode out the storm in a neighbor's basement.
I agree with LS's DH. I'm from Missouri, and growing up here, you hear the sirens going off so often that it's really easy to ignore them. They also test them so often that I've almost learned to tune them out completely. Now if the weather looks bad and I hear the sirens, I will check to see what the warning says. But I don't immediately assume that I need to get to the basement. I know it's better to be safe than sorry, but it's still hard to really blame people.
I would guess that a large part of the death toll & destruction is in the nature of the storm and its location as well. Some tornadoes/storm systems just allow for more advanced warning than others. Some develop so quickly, that advanced warning is not possible. I know that Joplin has been under tornado warning a number of times since this happened, and we've had strong storms all over the state all week. But none of those caused the level of destruction because the details were different. This particular tornado tore a path through a populated area, destroying the hospital, high school, churches, etc. And it sounds like it came on more quickly than anyone had thought. I read that the hospital heard the warning that they were expecting to be hit in 20 minutes, and the windows were being blown out 5 minutes later. I guess I just don't think anyone is to blame, and that this tragedy occurred mostly due to circumstance.
You'd be hard pressed to convince me that you guys hear sirens more often than we do here in Oklahoma. We have more tornadoes per square mile than any place on earth. I'm still thinking you guys don't get nearly enough warning - probably due to inexperienced weather men rather than hardcore meteorologists with the most expensive and advanced toys, and the psychology of the people. That's not blaming, it's a simple fact. Even in a place like this - home to the National Severe Storms Lab, where of all places the people should know better, this happens. But not as often, for the obvious reasons. To again put this in perspective, the May 3rd F5 tornado - one of nearly 60 - ploughed through a HIGHLY populated area: almost a thousand homes were scoured down to the foundations, and hundreds of others were badly damaged - and that was just ONE tornado's worth of damage in the metro, and yet only 41 were killed statewide that day. SOMETHING was different, you have to admit. (I have to add here that a friend of mine - currently going back to school for a meteorology degree - commented that a friend was in Dallas (don't recall if she said it was recent or not) and the TV cut in, said there was a tornado on the ground in Dallas and then went back to regular programming. WT....??? Her friend was totally freaked. That would NEVER happen here.)
http://www.latimes.com/health/boostershots/la-heb-joplin-tornado-missouri-20110524,0,1869581.story
I know I admit I get mightily annoyed when they blow sirens all over Oklahoma county, for a tornado say, on the eastern edge. (The county is 709 square miles). The "cry wolf" syndrome tends to come to the surface. But our guys on the whole are pretty good, and don't cry wolf very often, maybe because they know they'd be lynched more quickly if people died because they DIDN'T than were annoyed and inconvenieced because they DID. Add to that the fact that our "weathermen" are rockstars around here.
As I said, we had HOURS of notice. The local stations start the drum beat via the news that morning, and a the real coverage begins at about 2 and prempts everything on EVERY local station until the storms are literally out of the broadcast area. Every station has chasers EVERYWHERE, and tornado tracking down to the street level - with graphic maps superimposed on the radar. "The tornado is now crossing Waterloo Rd!" They have time estimates and track vectors for each cell(not tornadoes but each CELL), that change by the minute in realtime as the storm develops, with estimates of it hitting this community in 40 minutes, and that in 28, etc. They even tell you where the hail core is. You'd have to be near comatose to get caught with your pants down weatherwise here, especially now. (And in last year's epic hailstorm, I was complacent and got my car HAMMERED because I wasn't paying attention, so I know - with much chagrin - of which I speak)
Obviously there will be deaths, but dang! this year has been OTT. Maybe there's really no way around it, when in so many of the places, people just never give it serious credence, and in fairness, something like this season happens what? every 40 years or so? But still, very tragic in light of how well these things are predicted anymore.
Believe me, I'm NOT blaming. No one understands this better than an Okie. We remember the devastation very well indeed.
http://www.srh.noaa.gov/oun/?n=events-19990503-damage-mb
http://xpda.com/mooretornado/
Logan Sapphire|1306367925|2930310 said:It's my understanding that NSSL sends out alerts to the local weather people, so they should all be getting the same info that the NSSL is sending out and that local weather people aren't the ones responsible for thinking there should be an alert. Now I suppose one could argue that the weather people don't do a good enough job publicizing alerts, but my DH tells me that b/c Joplin is so close to OK (30 miles), northeast OK news stations service Joplin and vice versa. So if NE OK is getting an alert, so is Joplin.
I'm sure some of it does have to do with the crying wolf syndrome and people become complacent and used to hearing sirens being tested, etc. It's probably similar to a fire alarm- I'm sure not many people can say that they evacuate every single time they hear a fire alarm, even though you should. My sister's dorm in grad school had a fire alarm go off 3 times in one night- it was a prank, obviously, but not many people left the building all three times.
The other thing that might make a difference is that Joplin is built on top of old mine shafts. It's literally impossible for many people to have basements. Now one can argue the foolishness of having built a basement-less house in Tornado Alley, but that's what those folks had to deal with during the tornado. I'm only familiar with Joplin and not so much with the rest of the midwest but do most other midwestern homes come with basements? My best friend also lives in OKC and her house does not.