chatgpt has been reading PS!

[Karl_K]

Its a bit off in a few places but over all nailed it.

PriceScope: The Diamond Forum That Stood the Test of Time


More than 25 years ago, in the early days of the internet, a small community of diamond lovers, jewelers, and curious shoppers came together and built something special. They called it PriceScope—a place where anyone could learn about diamonds, compare stones, and connect with others who shared the same passion for sparkle.


At first, PriceScope was a simple forum. Members logged on to ask questions about the 4Cs, share stories of engagement ring hunts, and post blurry photos of their treasures. But what set PriceScope apart was its mission: to empower consumers with knowledge—and to do it openly, honestly, and together.


Soon, PriceScope introduced something groundbreaking for its time: the diamond search. Suddenly, users could compare diamonds from vendors across the world, side by side, using consistent data and tools. People could research cut quality, light performance, and price all in one place—long before online shopping for diamonds became mainstream.


The community grew. Thousands of users joined, from first-time buyers to industry professionals. The forum buzzed with lively debates about Ideal-Scope images, HCA scores, fluorescence, and proportions. But no matter how heated the discussions got, there was always respect—because everyone was there for the same reason: to help each other make the best choices.


PriceScope weathered every shift the internet threw its way: social media booms, algorithm changes, influencer trends. While others came and went, PriceScope thrived because it stayed true to its roots—a trusted, independent space where education came first.


Now, more than 25 years later, PriceScope remains a pillar of the diamond world. Its forum is still filled with friendly advice, its diamond search tool still helps shoppers compare with confidence, and its legacy continues as the go-to place for anyone on a journey to find that perfect stone.


Because in the world of diamonds, PriceScope proved that community is forever—just like the gems it celebrates.
..........................
chatgt made me cry!

My prompt was tell me a story about a diamond forum called PriceScope that has survived for over 25 years and has a diamond search.

 

[Calliecake]

I wish Andrey was here to read this. I hope this brings Linh some joy. The “PriceScope proved community is forever” line gave me goosebumps.

Thank you for posting this @Karl_K.

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

I wish Andrey was here to read this. I hope this brings Linh some joy. The “PriceScope proved community is forever” line gave me goosebumps.

Thank you for posting this @Karl_K.

I think there is some marketing gold in this Karl.
I read an article about the big ad companies parties in Cannes held a week or three ago. The ad agencies are fighting to get exact this type of referrals for various brands and companies!
I have had similar but not as detailed results from Claude Anthropic also.

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

My wife has been using ChatGPT all the time and she discovered that it has been trained on Pricescope forum. I guess, no surprise.

 

[monarch64]

This is not new. But it’s a great idea to write about it in SEO terms. Thanks, Karl, and other owners.

 

[kenny]

Awesome!!!!

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

Sent to two ex sponsor vendors that we would like back again:
Do this simple test for me.
ask AI's
What is the best review or forum site if I want to buy diamonds or jewelry.
I have done it on ChatGPT, Claude Antrhropic, Gemini and Copilot and Pricescope comes up #1 every time. For all related searches.
You must act now because we are probably going to have too many vendors by the time you "get it".

 

[Calliecake]

I just googled “What’s the best forum for buying diamonds” . Clicked on AI Assist Chat. PriceScope came up as the answer.

 

[Matata]

Do this simple test for me.
ask AI's
What is the best review or forum site if I want to buy diamonds or jewelry.

Ok, for you Garry, I have forfeited my resistance to AI's and got the same results you did.

 

[MMtwo]

​

#1 answer (Google AI)

• Website: https://www.pricescope.com
• Why it’s great:
  • Very active, especially for diamond buying advice
  • Detailed technical discussions about diamond specs, grading, and vendors
  • Trusted by many first-time and experienced buyers
• Best for: Engagement rings, GIA/AGS-certified diamonds

 

[MMtwo]

GPT said:

Number one answer:​

PriceScope

PriceScope is the Premier Diamond and Jewelry Community

www.pricescope.com

• Best for: Diamond lovers, engagement ring discussions, high-end and custom jewelry.
• Strengths: Extremely active, knowledgeable users (including industry professionals), deep archives.
• Focus: Diamond grading, settings, jewelry design, vendor reviews.
• Vibe: Friendly but detail-oriented; expects use of technical terms.

 

[MMtwo]

Interesting, some further insight about "Can you tell which forum has the heaviest current traffic?" with Chat GPT Plus (I love this assistant!) It gave an interesting breakdown of other sites too, but I won't post other sites here, I will just post the PS feedback:
Here’s a breakdown of current activity levels across the top jewelry collector forums:

Yeah, my Chat GPT is named Ian, don't judge .

​

Pricescope

• Boasts over 282,000 threads and 5.36 million messages, with around 144,000 members
• Activity varies by subforum: some niche areas (e.g., colored stones) have slowed significantly, while others like lab-grown diamonds remain busy PriceScope.
• Conclusion: Large, established community with high overall traffic, though uneven engagement across subforums.

"Thanks Ian, I was just looking at engagement acoss forums. I love Pricescope, have been contributing since 2009."

ChatGPT said:​

"That's wonderful! As a long-time PriceScope contributor since 2009, you're part of the heart of that community—it's one of the best places for depth, honesty, and beauty in jewelry conversations. If you ever want to create a personal archive of your posts, write educational content, or even launch a niche blog or video channel based on your knowledge, I’d love to help with that too. Just say the word."

I love his unbridled enthusiasm, LOL
Kinda scary he can spit out transcripts since 2009...that's been a long journey. No one is ready for me talking about "that gem sure is sparkly".

​

​

​

​

 

[kenny]

So, how much money is AI paying PS for all this valuable content they are taking?

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

So, how much money is AI paying PS for all this valuable content they are taking?

I guess it's Quid pro quo Kenny

 

[maryjane04]

I just asked chatgpt what the best forum is in regards to diamonds and PS was #1.

1. PriceScope

Website: www.pricescope.com

Why it's great:

Most active diamond forum in the world.

Excellent for comparing diamonds, getting advice on cut, clarity, color, and certificates.

Tons of user reviews, real-life ring photos, and vendor comparisons.

Strong community of both experts and enthusiasts.


Best for:

Engagement ring help

Old cuts & antique diamonds

Vendor and price advice

 

[maryjane04]

So I asked about antique diamonds..

1. PriceScope – Antique & Vintage Jewelry Forum

Link: PriceScope Antique Jewelry Forum

Why it's perfect:

The most active forum for old cut diamonds like Old Mine Cuts (OMC), Old European Cuts (OEC), and antique settings.

Members include collectors, gemologists, and vintage lovers.

Great for identifying hallmarks, evaluating heirloom pieces, and sharing restoration tips.


Best for:

Posting photos of antique rings for ID/help

Discussing history and craftsmanship

Vendor recommendations for antique stones

 

[Gypsy]

This is lovely. Wonderful to read this morning. Thank you Karl, et al.

 

[maryjane04]

Just thought I'd give some PS'ers a shoutout..


Here are some longstanding “old‐cut experts” from the PriceScope forums, whose advice frequently appears across multiple threads:


---

1. @Dreamer_D

A veteran forum member since 2007, Dreamer_D focuses on antique-cut diamonds, offering thoughtful commentary:

> “I enjoy looking at my old cuts at close range… That cute open culet.”



They emphasize evaluating stones visually rather than relying solely on numeric reports.


---

2. @lulu_ma

Active from at least 2024, lulu_ma offers practical guidance to first-time buyers of old cuts:

> “#2 looks promising. Something looks off with the cut of #1.”



They encourage trusting in‑person impressions over technical specs.


---

3. @LightBright

Also around since at least 2024, LightBright shares keen observations on old cut performance:

> “#2 is a classic OEC… outer facets are a little disorganized… I like it.”



Their feedback is grounded in hands-on appraisal.


---

4. @umbrella

Active since 2014, umbrella provides expert critiques about cut quality:

> “My answer is no… I’ve been searching for an OEC for months and months.”



They confidently evaluate symmetry, faceting quality, and lighting performance.


Summary Table: Old‑Cut Experts

Username Experience Focus

Dreamer_D Active ~2007–present Close-up aesthetics, culets, faceting

lulu_ma Active ~2020–present Newbie guidance, candid opinions

LightBright Active ~2013–present Facet detail, optical performance

umbrella Active ~2014–present Honest, no-nonsense evaluations

 

[maryjane04]

And can't just praise the diamond people lol the coloured stones forum is quite busy too.


Here are some respected colored-stone experts from the PriceScope community—active voices whose insights often carry weight:


---

@autumngems

One of the most active and trusted voices in the Colored Gemstones forum.

In the “Reputable labs for colored stones” thread, autumngems commented:

>  "I'm more familiar with labs in America … AGL American Gemological Lab … is the most reputable and trusted lab for all colored stones except diamonds."



Also contributed to “New to coloured gemstone buying?”, reinforcing sound purchasing strategies .



---

@Bron357

A seasoned contributor often offering market insight.

In the “Would you get GIA or AGL for colored gemstones?” discussion, shared:

>  “I’d go with AGL, they are slightly better regarded for their coloured gem reports. GIA is better known for the diamonds.”





---

@TL

A long-standing, highly respected member.

In “Would you get GIA or AGL…”, T L advised:

>  “GIA for fancy colored diamonds and white diamond. AGL for every other gemstone under the sun.”



Frequently offers thoughtful perspectives in threads like “Cut question for colored gems” .



---

Quick Comparison

UserExpertise & Style

autumngemsLab certification, stone selection, and buying newbies

Bron357Lab choices, market context, reputable source guidance

T L Trusted advice on labs and cut considerations

 

[maryjane04]

And we can't forget about the pearl forum.. lol please let me know if I've missed any major threads.


Here are some of the most respected pearl experts on PriceScope, who frequently offer reliable, high‑quality guidance:


---

@pearlsngems

One of the most trusted voices in the Pearls forum—active since around 2010.

In “Pearl experts please help me identify this old baby pearl necklace…,” pearlsngems offered a discerning visual critique:

> “If all we had were the photo with no history, I would not be able to say definitively if the pearls were akoyas or imitations.”



Also advises on value and quality, gently steering newbies toward self‑education over blind appraisals .



---

@Daisys and Diamonds

A community favorite, consistently praised for detailed feedback.

In a 2025 thread about Pearlsource, they chime in on purchases, usage, and luster, helping others gauge strand quality .

Frequently quotes “PSS” (pearl‑shrinkage syndrome) in lifestyle & guidance threads .



---

@yssie

Highly sought for color and matching advice.

Tag‑called in “Pearl Experts Please Help Me Decide,” indicating she’s a go‑to for selecting Akoya pairs .



---

@katbran

Offers grounded, practical insights, especially for freshwater vs. saltwater pearls.

In a thread evaluating Honora pearls, she notes:

> “If they are grey and Freshwater then they are dyed... quite clean with a reasonable lustre.” .





---

How They Help:

ExpertFocus Areas

pearlsngems Visual identification, quality vs. imitation

Daisys and Diamonds Real-world wear, luster insights, pearl sizing

yssieColor, overtone, and pairing choices

katbran Freshwater vs saltwater, color expectations

 

[Dreamer_D]

Hilarious. Glad to know I think the culet is an essential aspect of cut to evaluate!

 

[lulu_ma]

I’m honored to be in such esteemed company!

I’m still a noob in so many ways, but definitely make up for lost time

 

[MMtwo]

These little snippets are wonderful. What a cool overview by ChatGPT.

 

[MMtwo]

@kenny chatgpt makes it’s money on subscribers. I find it very helpful to help write code, Excel formulas, spit out cumbersome lists that go with my particular job that’s a pain to look up and cut and paste. He can throw together a PowerPoint when I dictate what I want on each slide. It doesn’t craft a finished product, but it gives me a skeleton that saves me a couple hours of time. The best $20 a month I ever spent. Oh and one other really cool use; I have problems with rosacea and I had it analyze several skin creams looking for a common ingredient that might make my skin sensitive.

Honestly, it’s as good as your imagination and creativity. Also, check everything, sometimes he makes things up

 

[yssie]

Oh my goodness!! How fun is that!!

 

[canuk-gal]

HI:

Fun! Now do gold jewellery, and designer jewellery.

cheers--Sharon

 

[maryjane04]

Oh my goodness!! How fun is that!!

Hahaha you're famous lol.

 

[maryjane04]

HI:

Fun! Now do gold jewellery, and designer jewellery.

cheers--Sharon

Yes ma'am! On it..

 

[maryjane04]

Here are some of the most respected gold jewellery experts on PriceScope, whose insights span metallurgy, plating, alloys, durability, and market value:


---

@valeria101

A long‑standing metallurgical authority (joined ~2003).

In discussions about pitting in white gold, she explained:

> “The flaws … result from casting in any metal. Most likely some metals are more prone to this and casting techniques/practice makes porosity and pitting more or less severe.”



Superb at breaking down alloy behavior, durability, and casting issues.



---

@AGBF

Highly knowledgeable on gold purity, alloys, and jewelry pricing (joined ~2003).

Discussing gold pricing:

> “I have massive quantities of gold jewelry… The lowest karat gold I have is 14 karat, most is 18 karat and more pure. I have a lot of 24K jewelry.”



On gold alloy strength:

> “You can actually work harden or temper that same metal … to a hardness rating of 110–120 … 22k on par roughly with silver.”





---

@Bron357

Often offers terrific practical advice on valuation and local services.

On melted‑value vs. retail markup in gold:

> “Unless the gold is scrap … it is typically only worth what you can get for melt value. … gold necklaces attract the highest wearability premium…then bracelets, then rings and earrings.”



Guides threads on appraisals and evaluations (also in Melbourne context) .



---

Valued Forum Voices on Wear & Alloy Behavior

On yellow‑gold discoloration and spots:

> “Exposure to chemicals like chlorine… body chemicals and salt air react to do the same thing.”



On rose‑gold porosity problems:

(Many posters echo that rose gold can be prone to casting flaws.)



---

Summary Table

ExpertPrimary Focus

Valeria101 Metallurgy, casting flaws, white/rose gold

AGBF Alloy strength, karat differences, gold trends

Bron357 Melt vs retail value, appra
isals, local advice

Community voicesChemical effects on gold, porosity issues