Can't decide - Need quick decision

[cantdecide]

Hi all!

I've learned a lot from this board and now that I've narrowed down my choices, I hope that you can provide some insight on which diamond you'd prefer.

Note: I should add that both of these are from online vendors therefore I don't have photos.

#1
http://i.imgur.com/E9BQ69Q.png

#2
http://i.imgur.com/o1oXbT1.png

Thanks!

-cantdecide

 

[Deez]

Depending on the price difference I like #1. Bigger, slightly better light return, and clarity won't be a factor between those two.

 

[cantdecide]

Depending on the price difference I like #1. Bigger, slightly better light return, and clarity won't be a factor between those two.

Thanks for your reply! I know I'm splitting hairs at this point. I'm not sure if #2 justifies the $600 price difference. Just looking for reassurance .

 

[Gypsy]

Is #1 eyeclean? They are both nice. I have a preference for the first one due to spread. But the second one is lovely and at VS1 will definitely be eyeclean.