Can''t choose - please give me your opinion

fran · Aug 15, 2006

I''ve found 2 diamonds on James Allen site - customer service rep said both are eyeclean. Why is the second more when the specs are so similar? And the 6.60 measurement for the first diamond doesn''t sound right - too big a spread?

GIA specs
#1

1.07 round
H/SI1
thin to medium girdle
very good symmetry /polish
no flluorescence
6.60 x 6.67 x 4.05mm
HCA score - 1.2
crown - 34.5
pavilion - 40.8
$5,072.00

GIA specs
#2
1.04 round
H/ SI 1
very good symmetry/polish
no flluorescence
thin to medium girdle
6.53 x 6.56 x 3.98mm
HCA score: 1.3
crown 34.5
pavillion 40.8
$5,513.00

whatmeworry · Aug 15, 2006

Well the specs look the same because of GIA rounding. The angles could really be different in real life. As for the price difference, I don''t know maybe different suppliers. Maybe one is a high H (closer to a G in color). Lot''s of different reasons.