Can you compare these two stone specs for me? Advice needed! THANKS!

[GolfGirl2008]

I already own the first stone but am unhappy with how the ring is set so might get the second stone instead. The question is to do a stone for stone switch or get the first one reset. The second stone is set just how I want the first one set. Can you tell me how these two specs compare? I apologize for not having pics. THANKS!

FIRST STONE:
RB 2.31 CARATS
8.65 - 8.69 x 5.14 mm
G color
VVS2 clarity
Faint fluorescence
Cut: Excellent
Symmetry: Excellent
Polish: VG
Total depth %: 59.3%
Table size %: 60%
Crown angle: 33.5°
Pavillion depth %: 43.5%
Culet: none
Girdle: thin to slightly thick, faceted
HCA score: 1.8, with a VG, VG, VG, Ex rating

SECOND STONE:

RB 2.35 CARATS
8.53 - 8.62 x 5.27 mm
G color
VS1 clarity
Faint fluorescence
Cut: Excellent
Symmetry: VG
Polish: VG
Total depth %: 61.5%
Table size %: 58%
Crown angle: 33.5°
Pavillion depth %: 43.5%
Culet: none
Girdle: thin to slightly thick, faceted
HCA score: 1.4 with a Ex, Ex, Ex, Vg rating