shape
carat
color
clarity

Wedding Bridesmaids dilemma

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

rockzilla

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Nov 19, 2006
Messages
1,286
My fiance and I have decided on having 3 attendants each. This is to keep costs down, keep the wedding less formal, and match up both sides.

That being said, I have 3 slots and 4 potential bridesmaids. This is how it breaks down:

(I know its kind of offensive that I have given my good friends numbers instead of names, but I''m trying to keep it as anonymous/easy to understand as possible!)

1. Best friend since 7th grade, lives here in SF (wedding will be in SoCal, but I''m in SF for a few more months) She is definitely MOH, no questions.

2. Good friend from high school, lives on the east coast, is getting married this summer but a very small, backyard wedding (no attendants, no walking down the aisle, etc, only me and friend #1 from HS will be there as friends). She''s already been a bridesmaid a couple of times, don''t know for sure if she''d be into it (kind of a non-traditional gal) plus would be difficult from 3,000 miles away but not impossible.

3. Good friend from college, lived in the same dorm with me - the only candidate actually IN LA. Also, this girl gets stuff DONE...not that the MOH wouldn''t, but she is really on top of things, is a major planner, and is located near the wedding and she''d be really excited about getting involved with stuff.

4. Other friend from college - she lives in Europe right now but is up in the air where she''ll be living at the time of the wedding. She has said she''ll come back for it. I was a bridesmaid in her wedding last year, and I think she''s expecting (hoping more appropriate) to be asked this time. But, at the time she asked me, I remember thinking "wow this is really nice, but if I were getting married I probably would not have asked her"

So, out of friends 2, 3, and 4, I have to choose two to ask to be bridesmaids. If I were choosing in terms of importance to me, I would likely pick 2 & 3 (though 4 and I have gotten closer since her wedding). But, I do think that #4 would be much more excited about it, whereas #2 might just say yes out of obligation. I think I will ask friend 3 regardless, as I think I''d go crazy with all of my bridesmaids in different parts of the world and nooone local.

Right now, my plan is to see #2 next week when I am back home, and just tell her since she''s really important to me, I''d love for her to be involved in the wedding in some way - but if she doesn''t want the hassle of buying a dress, etc that I totally understand and won''t feel offended. Then, depending on her answer, I can decide whether or not to ask friend #4.
Is this OK? There is no chance of friend #4 finding out - they''ve never met each other - so she won''t think she''s the "second choice" which she really isn''t - if we were having 4, she''d definitely be asked.
 
I think in the end you would be happier having someone who says yes because they are excited, versus saying yes out of obligation. Either way I don''t feel like being in someone''s wedding makes you obligated to have them in yours. I think it sounds like the first girl would have trouble making arrangements to get there, and would probably be asking more from you in the end. Both are far away for fittings so no opinion there. Also I think having two girls who you were friends with in college might make things more amiable and easier for people to get to know one another. Great choice for the MOH btw.
 
Rockzilla - You did a fantastic job of explaining all of that and I understand completely what you are experiencing!

To answer your question ... yes, I believe, that what you have suggested is perfect! Based on your descriptions of 2, 3 and 4, I would have suggested the same.

I''m experiencing something similar with my bridesmaids options right now and I know how complicated, "political" and even hurtful it can get so ... good luck and I''m sure that everything will work out wonderfully for you and, regardless, you will have 3 people you care about standing up for you at your wedding.
9.gif
 
Hmmm I agree that friends 3 and 4 seem good to me, especially since #2 might not be as into it. I do however think you need to decide before running it by #2. I have a feeling that even if you say all that about not being offended if she doesnt want to wear the dress etc, she will probably be honored and will probably say yes to being bridesmaid. Are you secretly hoping she will say no so you can ask #4?
 
Well, this isn't what you asked but I'd have #1 and #3 for sure. I'd ask number 2 if she's interested very honestly. If she says no, I'd ask #4 if I REALLY wanted the numbers even. But I would just cut it back to 2 attendants.
 
Maybe ask #2 to do something else, like the guestbook or other day-of things to feel included without having to actually be in the wedding.
 
Rockzilla,

1, 3, 4 oh my gosh, it feels like I just gave you opinons on a dress. Honestly, I think anyone who you think might be a so-so into it, I eliminate. My SIL had one of those as a MoH. Disaster. The girl didn''t even attend the WEDDING. And not because of bad blood. She just didn''t feel like it.
 
I don''t think she''d be so not into it as to not show up - if she made the committment I think she would be happy to be involved. The only thing is, we are sort of "bonding" over her planning the wedding this summer...originally she wanted 20 people in the backyard, non-white wedding dress...her parents have pushed her a bit, so its up to ~40 people (still in the backyard) and a gorgeous - but knee length - white melissa sweet dress. She wanted very casual, nontraditional, etc.

I''m just imaging her thinking "Another wedding thing...." and being overwhelmed, but I don''t have any doubts that she would buy the dress & come if I really really asked her.

Also, the MOH really wants me to ask #2 ("You have to ask her!") because she feels she would be hurt not to be asked. So I will definitely ask her...

RZ
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top