Between Two Stars

[aristotle]

Hello all,

Suppose you have two rocks:

Diamond #1:
F - VS1
Star facet : 55%
Lower half: 75%

Diamond #2:
E - VS1
Star facet: 50%
Lower half: 75%

Which one would you choose, other things being equal? Would the 5% star facet discrepancy between Diamonds #1 and #2 affect the brilliance significantly?

Thanks!

 

[AGBF]

I'm glad to see that you are asking again, aristotle. As I said in your previous thread, I cannot help you with this matter!

Deb/AGBF

 

[delight]

Not much of a difference between 5% on a GIA report. Information you gave is insufficient for any sort of assessment. Start with images and the rest of the proportions.