- Joined
- Dec 31, 2006
- Messages
- 4,750
I had my make up done this weekend by MAC. I didn't particularly care for the artist, she didn't seem too interested in making me happy with the final result, and got kind of annoyed when I asked if I could periodically look in the mirror so I could see what she was doing as she was going along. The overall look ended up OK, and looked fine in pictures (my sister took a few) but:
- I had layers and layers and layers of foundation. To the point that I was embarrassed to be walking around like that afterwards.
- They used primer on my lids which I believe made them look extra wrinkly/crinkly.
- They used all shimmery shadows which don't help the wrinkly/crinkly lid effect.
I would post pictures, but wish I could include the whole face, as I think that if I include just the eyes you won't get the full effect at all. If anyone knows how to take down or delete pictures after they're posted, let me know. But maybe I'll post a few of just the eyes later.
I then went to Saphora and had a guy there do my makeup.
- He did the skin part way better - I had plenty of coverage and looked good in pictures but I wasn't wearing a mask. I should point out that in BOTH cases the makeup really settled into the wrinkles under my eyes and around my mouth (even though they both used primer).
- He lined my eyes with liquid liner. I felt it was way too harsh in person, and in pictures, but he told me you need that for the eyes to look defined.
- Didn't use a primer - my lids looked way less wrinkly/crinkly. (finding that out was worth its weight in gold)
- He did my eyes with all shimmery shades. When I asked him if he could try some matte shades on me, or a combo, he said not to do anything other than shimmer, that matte makeup will look "dirty" and that the shimmer colors are much better/prettier.
The look of my eyes in the pictures from the Sephora guy was HIDEOUS. He did one eye with greens/golds/bronzes, the other with pinks/purples. I looked like an OVERDONE CLOWN both instances. Not to mention, all kinds of colors doesn't suit me, or a wedding overlooking the beach while it's still daylight! But he kept telling me that for the pictures, you must go overboard.
I am all for doing what is needed for the pictures, but I want to feel good in person, too. So here are my questions
- Must foundation be caked on for skin to look good in pictures?
- Must shimmery shades be used and/or can they be combined with matte shades? (I feel like shimmer can make people look older, especially if they don't have awesome/taut skin - I'm 38, and my skin is OK, but not particularly taut) again,
- Can a defined eye be achieved w/o liquid eyeliner or do you need strong definition that only liquid eyeliner can give?
- Dark brown eyeliner and mascara enough for eyes to pop or must black be used? (I think black is too harsh for me)
I am planning on going to another MAC and perhaps a few other counters, and I want to be able to tell them "I don't want A, B, C and D".
Thanks!
- I had layers and layers and layers of foundation. To the point that I was embarrassed to be walking around like that afterwards.
- They used primer on my lids which I believe made them look extra wrinkly/crinkly.
- They used all shimmery shadows which don't help the wrinkly/crinkly lid effect.
I would post pictures, but wish I could include the whole face, as I think that if I include just the eyes you won't get the full effect at all. If anyone knows how to take down or delete pictures after they're posted, let me know. But maybe I'll post a few of just the eyes later.
I then went to Saphora and had a guy there do my makeup.
- He did the skin part way better - I had plenty of coverage and looked good in pictures but I wasn't wearing a mask. I should point out that in BOTH cases the makeup really settled into the wrinkles under my eyes and around my mouth (even though they both used primer).

- He lined my eyes with liquid liner. I felt it was way too harsh in person, and in pictures, but he told me you need that for the eyes to look defined.
- Didn't use a primer - my lids looked way less wrinkly/crinkly. (finding that out was worth its weight in gold)
- He did my eyes with all shimmery shades. When I asked him if he could try some matte shades on me, or a combo, he said not to do anything other than shimmer, that matte makeup will look "dirty" and that the shimmer colors are much better/prettier.
The look of my eyes in the pictures from the Sephora guy was HIDEOUS. He did one eye with greens/golds/bronzes, the other with pinks/purples. I looked like an OVERDONE CLOWN both instances. Not to mention, all kinds of colors doesn't suit me, or a wedding overlooking the beach while it's still daylight! But he kept telling me that for the pictures, you must go overboard.
I am all for doing what is needed for the pictures, but I want to feel good in person, too. So here are my questions
- Must foundation be caked on for skin to look good in pictures?
- Must shimmery shades be used and/or can they be combined with matte shades? (I feel like shimmer can make people look older, especially if they don't have awesome/taut skin - I'm 38, and my skin is OK, but not particularly taut) again,

- Can a defined eye be achieved w/o liquid eyeliner or do you need strong definition that only liquid eyeliner can give?
- Dark brown eyeliner and mascara enough for eyes to pop or must black be used? (I think black is too harsh for me)
I am planning on going to another MAC and perhaps a few other counters, and I want to be able to tell them "I don't want A, B, C and D".
Thanks!