Are either of these Pears worth my time (grade reports and picture included)

[Mike6636]

I have been dealing with a local jeweler. These are the 2 best he has found for me so far. I was hoping to buy local but am now considering whether I should try somewhere else due to price. Playing around I was searching the net trying to see if I could find these stones online and suprisingly I did. Anyways, with the info provided: could either of these 2 stones be worth-while for me?

Thanks a ton!

http://www.sylviasantiques.com/diamond-0-87-carats-color-d-clarity-si1.html

http://www.sylviasantiques.com/diamond-0-74-carats-color-g-clarity-vs1-4.html

Thank you!

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

They are totally different size, clarity etc.
The .84 is a different style of cut and is very shallow / spready - I would like to see an ASET for both.

Also consider the vendors who give more info - then we can help you more

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 1/23/2010 7:55:24 PM
Author:Mike6636
I have been dealing with a local jeweler. These are the 2 best he has found for me so far. I was hoping to buy local but am now considering whether I should try somewhere else due to price. Playing around I was searching the net trying to see if I could find these stones online and suprisingly I did. Anyways, with the info provided: could either of these 2 stones be worth-while for me?

Thanks a ton!

http://www.sylviasantiques.com/diamond-0-87-carats-color-d-clarity-si1.html

http://www.sylviasantiques.com/diamond-0-74-carats-color-g-clarity-vs1-4.html

Thank you!

Hi Mike,

Lets take a look....

My thoughts are the same as Garry's, the first is shallow depthed and for both an ASET image would be most useful if this vendor can supply them. From the info we have, I prefer the second but images such as ASET would be really useful if these are your main contenders in order to evaluate the light return.