ssharma1121
Rough_Rock
- Joined
- Aug 22, 2008
- Messages
- 32
So I had my wonderful 1.77 ct RB solitaire ring appraised by Michael Jordan at AGA. I asked about appraisal questions in a previous post and put a list together and brought it with me. Well, in 2 hours we only got up to question #3 (does the ring match the certificate?). Why? Because the answer to question #3 is NO! Mr. Jordan had to come up with his own plot because the ring and certificate were completely different. My certificate shows a few inclusions and feathers on the table. My stone has all of its inclusions and feathers on the facets and nothing on the table. The problem is that we bought this stone from UD without looking at the certificate. We bought the stone based on Jeff''s opinion. Now that the stone and certificate don''t match, I don''t know if this really was the stone Jeff was looking at or if there was a mix-up and they sent us the wrong certificate. Mr. Jordan was very kind and thorough and said it was up to me and my fiance on what to do. We can keep the stone, or return it and ask for a GIA stone. I like the stone (eyeclean except when looking through the pavilion) but this lack of a match between the certificate and stone bothers me. What would you do?
By the way, I loved AGA. If I ever need any jewelry appraised ever again, that''s where I would go.
By the way, I loved AGA. If I ever need any jewelry appraised ever again, that''s where I would go.