Advice on this diamond

[bmendick1]

Hi guys, I know my other thread got pretty crazy with that IS image, but I'm hoping you guys can evaluate this stone for me objectively. I realize there's a very good chance the IS was fake, but if you guys could just look at these pics and give me your feedback is appreciate it. If there are any other angles or lighting environments you'd like to see I'll be happy to post more!! Thanks!!

 

[SMC]

Just a thought, but you might get more responses if you started by apologizing (on here or the other thread) to JulieN first.

I think that the only thing you can evaluate yourself is whether or not it's eye clean. And if it looks good to you, you should keep it. In the absence of another diamond to compare it to, your diamond is going to look great. Photographs don't really tell you anything, that's why you needed the IS image in the first place.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

The diamond looks fine. I think that is really what you are wanting to hear.

However, I will never understand considering buying something from someone who appeared to be trying to deceive you.

 

[Karl_K]

The diamond looks fine. I think that is really what you are wanting to hear.

However, I will never understand considering buying something from someone who appeared to be trying to deceive you.

Big ditto!!
Why would one want to do business with a company that would pull that?

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

Hello all,

For the record, we have invited the employee or the owner of brilliance.com to come explain the ideal-scope situation.
I hope he will do so, either in this thread or in the original thread where the issue was raised:
https://www.pricescope.com/forum/rockytalky/need-expert-help-t186404-30.html?uid=1006

 

[CopperTop]

I don't care about anybody's feeling here and I think those pics are useless. You are too impatient to research before you buy and took some blurry pictures. Nobody has enough information to help you. Congrats on buying a diamond. It's shiny and expensive. Great job. Whatever.

 

[SMC]

I don't care about anybody's feeling here and I think those pics are useless. You are too impatient to research before you buy and took some blurry pictures. Nobody has enough information to help you. Congrats on buying a diamond. It's shiny and expensive. Great job. Whatever.

This response was also uncalled for. OP, despite still trusting the vendor, I think the only way you can get an accurate picture of how good the light performance is to get an Idealscope. You can purchase your own if you can get your hands on one (not that expensive). Otherwise, if the diamond is eye clean and you like the way it looks under a variety of lighting conditions, you should keep it.

Please verify that the diamond is the same as the one you got the GIA certificate for!

 

[luv2lift]

Hi Gary, I respect your opinion and wanted to know if I could ask for your thoughts on a stone/ASET without using Pricescope. Do you have a work email I could contact you through? Thank you in advance.

 

[TitanCi]

I don't care about anybody's feeling here and I think those pics are useless. You are too impatient to research before you buy and took some blurry pictures. Nobody has enough information to help you. Congrats on buying a diamond. It's shiny and expensive. Great job. Whatever.

and... the dick of the year award goes to....