Advice on these ideal scopes?

[dttd]

Hey everyone. I have these 3 diamonds on hold for the next 48 hours. Any insight/opinions with regard to the images would be much appreciated! The gemologist recommended diamond 362028 (1st link) as it offered the best light return and had great proportions

https://www.pricescope.com/files/images/362028id_0.jpg

1.15 carat g vs2 excellent cut
HCA =1

https://www.pricescope.com/files/images/361789id_0.jpg

This is a 1.2 carat h vs2 excellent cut
HCA = 1.8

https://www.pricescope.com/files/images/182765id.jpg

This is a 1.15 h vs1 excellent
HCA = 1.4

 

[alpackie]

Experts can correct me if I'm wrong, but 2nd and 3rd look to me like they have more light leakage in between the arrows and in the girdle. I like the first one if I had to choose from the 3, but it isn't that symmetrical.

 

[dttd]

Thanks for the thoughts. I too noticed the symmetry issue. Would that be something noticeable at all? I ordered the ideal scopes with the intention of choosing the diamond with the least amount of light leakage.

 

[HappyNewLife]

I'd probably go for the first one. It's also a grade up in color, and anything below a G I can see.