Advice between two round diamonds

[vinscor]

Hi everybody,

I need to make a decision between 2 stones. I was given a video of the 2 and here is the link:

http://www.youtube.com/diamondinfoman#p/u/0/Fra3hRCAIUI

The one on the right is a 1.14 VS1 F cut ideal symmetry ideal and polish excellent.

The one on the right is 1.07 VS1 E ideal ideal ideal.

About the brillance, sparkle and fire I'm conviced the 1.14 does as well as the 1.07. What I'm concerned about is the colour (F vs E). It seems to me that the colour is quite different and that the F colour is quite yellowish for a F. Is it just me? Am I imagining this?

The 1.07 is also 2000 dollars more. Let me know if you think that difference in price is worth it, also considering the 1.07 stone is a bit smaller, but the lady does not mind too much as long as it is above 1.00.

Thank you very much

 

[Unknown]

I couldn't see any defference between two of them except size, so I would go for the larger one.

 

[vinscor]

Thanks, it seems to be the consensus .

 

[sparkL]

They're both achingly beautiful. I can't detect any color in the F stone. Given that the E is smaller and $2000 more I think you should definitely go with the F.

I hadn't seen any of these GOG videos on YouTube before your post pointed me to them. Jonathan is really on to something there -- he does a great job capturing on video what makes good diamonds look good. I felt myself reaching for my credit card.