ACA I color, or Expert Selections G?

[diamondgal3429]

Hello,

I''m trying to decide between a couple of diamonds at Whiteflash. One of them is ACA, but it is I color, SI1 Clarity. Scores a 1.1 on the HCA and good angles. The other is an Expert Selections, G color and VS1 Clarity, a 1.8 on the HCA and also good angles. Aside from the color and clarity, the only difference appears to be in the symmetry, the ACA is AGS Ideal, and the Expert Selections stone is GIA Very Good (not excellent). Does the downgrade in symmetry make a visible difference? When I look at the ideal scope image of the Expert Selections stone it looks almost as precise as the ACA stone! I thought that the symmetry would be way off but it doesn''t appear to be, I have to struggle to find the differences.

Thanks for the feedback!

 

[Skippy123]

The ACA would be very lovely; do you have links to the diamonds? I bet the ES is lovely too. Is there a difference in price? Which do you like better? Which is bigger?

 

[Kaleigh]

I'd go for the ES G. ES stones just miss the ACA mark, and are an excellent value.

Agreeing with Skippy, can you give us the links?? At this time of year, best to put a hold on one of them..... FYI!!!!