58T, 36 CA, 40.6 PA. Can this combo be considered as SUPER IDEAL?

[Stephhhen]

Hi all, I am looking for a ring for my GF and then found this diamond.

What do you think of this proportion? Can it be considered as super ideal? Is the carat weight wasted due to the steep CA?



Here is the GIA report. https://www.gia.edu/report-check?reportno=1339117846

Thank you very much in advance!!

 

[Karl_K]

Its generally outside of what many people consider the super-ideal range but it could be a very well cut diamond with top level light performance. The gross rounding of the GIA numbers means they are rather useless for this combination of proportions to give a resonable idea of what it will do.
Do you have any images? IS or ASET would help the most.

 

[Stephhhen]

I really wish I could get the ASET images, but no luck.
I have a rough video of it. (diamond on the bottom/right).

DiamondComparison - Streamable

Check out this video on Streamable using your phone, tablet or desktop.

streamable.com

Also, how do those two compare to each other just from the terrible video?
Here is the GIA report for the other one: https://www.gia.edu/report-check?reportno=7336221443

 

[Karl_K]

same thing with the other one.
video isnt very helpful.