2 IS images - pick the best!

[Baja]

Which diamond has the better light performance based on the IS images? 1 or 2.
Diamond 1

Diamond 2

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I am not sure what is going on over on the right side of #1...is it an inclusion? But from what I see, I'd choose #2. But I'd never choose a stone based on the IS alone. I'd need to see the report and magnified images of the stone.

 

[minmin001]

based on the pic. #2

 

[yssie]

Neither. Both. Tossup, unless you have particularly strong feelings on painting.

I think DS is right about the inclusion - are both eyeclean to your specifications?