Without pictures and additional information . . . the bigger one.
And not that the numbers are as important as what they look like in person, but the depth/table of #2 are close to my Asscher (my table is 57%). Take them both for walks in different lighting conditions, set it in a setting similar to the direction you're going to see how it might behave once set, and go from there. Good luck! Take pics for us once you make a decision.