shape
carat
color
clarity

2.6-2.89ct F SI1/VS2 cushion or 3.0ct+ G SI1/VS2 cushion?

jayts22

Rough_Rock
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
1
Hi this if my first post, I have been doing as much research as possible and this site so far as been the most informative.

The 2 stones above basically fit into my price range with the wholesaler I just started working with, It was just chance I stumbled into his store and I was amazed at the hundreds of loose GIA diamonds he had and the prices are really good, which has increased the size I can now afford.

I spoke with him yesterday and we narrowed down the types of stones above, I really want an F color but he highly recommended a G saying I or my fiance will never tell the difference and I can get larger, but then he showed me an F next to a G and I saw right away. I also went to color guide on GOG and saw the difference as well. I think the average increase in price I was seeing was about 6k more for the F assuming same cut and clarity, however he said he likely could get me in a much much bigger G.

He is going to pull many of the ones he has at jewelers next week so he can show me, and I will have a chance to view a ton of stones all at once.

I want to know if it is worth it for the F, my fiance is color sensitive and has fair skin, she is a redhead, and this stone will sit inside a halo type setting. This is going to be a good size diamond on her finger and I am really concerned that the G will be noticeable, I dont ever want one of her friends talking behind her back if they notice any warmth in the stone, they have smaller diamonds but I know from their husbands that they are F or higher rated. If I can be convince by a disinterested person that the F will be the better buy, I will go that way.

Thanks for your help in advance, I have read a lot of f/g posts but none have really gone over stones like the ones I am going for...Thanks
 
Re: 2.6-2.89ct F SI1/VS2 cushion or 3.0ct+ G SI1/VS2 cushion

If you can detect a color difference and you DISLIKE it, get the F. It doesn't really matter if you can see a difference and DON'T dislike the color of G - in that case you cold get the larger stone. However, if you dislike the G, get the F. Lots of people are not color sensitive, but in this case both you and your GF are - and you are the only people who matter. If you get a color below your level of comfort, you will always be unhappy with it.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top