1.34-1.35ct G/VS1 Round Help! Which one to choose!! & price?

[LILAC200341021]

Hi there!

I've posted the certificates for both (Diamond #1 & Diamond #2).

And please help me determine which certificate looks better or if there are any concerns with the quality and measurements!

For Diamond #1, the seller claimed it is "Hearts & Arrows", is there a common standard for it?

Also, about the price, $12,700 for Diamond #1 vs. $12,960 for Diamond #2.

Which diamond would you choose for the related quality and measurements?

Thanks in advance for your help! It is very much appreciated!

BD

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Re: 1.34-1.35ct G/VS1 Round Help! Which one to choose!! & pr

I believe I would take #1. I like the 56 table and the higher crown angle. I think the prices are fine. My diamond is G VS1, too!

Do you have pictures or idealscope images of these stones by chance?

 

[LILAC200341021]

Re: 1.34-1.35ct G/VS1 Round Help! Which one to choose!! & pr

THANKS A LOT!!!

I LIKE #1, JUST THE GRAINING ON THE REPORT MAKES ME CONCERNED...

SINCE THOSE ARE LISTED PRICES, SHOULD I NEGOTIATE ON THE PRICE? OR YOU THINK THEY ARE PRETTY REASONABLE ALREADY?

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Re: 1.34-1.35ct G/VS1 Round Help! Which one to choose!! & pr

I would always negotiate just to see, but I think the prices are okay. I was looking recently at that range up through 1.5's, and I know that a top hearts and arrows 1.35 G VS1 was priced around the $16k range. So these look good to me. I don't think you have to worry about anything with a G VS1 triple excellent stone! I think the other one would be fine, too.

 

[Amys Bling]

Re: 1.34-1.35ct G/VS1 Round Help! Which one to choose!! & pr

looks good I like the first one!

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Re: 1.34-1.35ct G/VS1 Round Help! Which one to choose!! & pr

I would just add that the second one gets a better HCA score, but I have learned that we miss a lot of gorgeous diamonds when we eliminate all that score over 2. For that reason, it is really good when we can see an idealscope image, but I think that most GIA excellent stones are going to look really great to most people.